Unfortunately the primary use-case of antibiotics is actually in livestock. In the US, 80% of antibiotics produced in 2011 went to livestock[1].
[1]: http://www.motherjones.com/tom-philpott/2011/07/what-usda-do...
Re:The case for an antibiotics tax
by ImprovedSilence on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:18AM
(#7057794)
RTFA. It's a tax for use of antibiotics on livestock, not humans.
RTA yourself (and then I'd appreciate an apology).
The article is proposing that the tax be applied to every use: "But why limit it to farms?".
Re:The case for an antibiotics tax
by ericcumbee on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:25AM
(#7057840)
Which the cost will be passed along to the consumer.
Re:The case for an antibiotics tax
by potatolicious on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:59AM
(#7058093)
And rightly so. There's no good reason why we should have cheap meat if the cost is hugely increasing our susceptibility to global pandemic.
OP was talking about taxing human-use antibiotics - i.e., we shouldn't do things that will increase the price of drugs that people literally need to avoid dying.
I'm sorry that you've been downvoted - because you are right.
This is a tax on poor people that won't affect the majority of readers... it increases the minimum cost of producing meat.
If we can't figure out high-production meat farming then eventually we're saying that meat should be something only for the wealthy.
If it's a choice between meat being something only for the wealthy and a prevalence of untreatable bacteriological infections, I'm going to go with the former.
Maybe the wealthy should stop eating meat too. Is it okay to torture animals for pleasure? If it is, then we should repeal the laws we currently have against it. But if it's wrong - as most people would say it is - then maybe we should stop behaving as though it becomes okay when it's done out of sight.
Re:The case for an antibiotics tax
by sliverstorm on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:27PM
(#7060530)
So in what way do we restrict access to antibiotics to prevent their abuse (to the great detriment of all of humanity)?
We should not seek to increase the price of this for the least well-off in society.
This would potentially have a net negative effect as it allows bacterial infection to spread, requiring increased antibiotic use.
Besides, a tax on use wouldn't impact upon doctor's behaviour in the desired way (reduce non-essential use): since the doctor is still making a net profit from the prescription and it (still) acts as a convenient placebo.