Even with incremental compilation and SBT subprojects (i.e. modules to keep recompiled code to a minimum) there's a compile time hit on _every_ source file change; that adds up over the lifetime of a project.
You guys may be more productive now than you were with PHP, but that's likely due more to the awesome libraries you're using than Scala development being inherently faster than PHP.
That's partly why Dynamic came about in Scala, to deal with the case where, shit, you've already got a type safe represention of an object in Scala, and now you have to create a type safe JSON version of the same -- pointless double duty...PHP, Python, Groovy, Ruby, etc. win this particular battle.
I am, BTW, completely playing devil's advocate here ;-), Scala's my daily bread; PHP, wow, I did some horrible things [shudder]
I am just glad to be done with PHP.
> I am just glad to be done with PHP
shhhh, this is, you know, a PHP thread ;-)
heh, that's a stretch, perhaps compared to 3 years ago the IDE story in Scala is all roses. It's improved with time, but I still get arggghhh inducing moments where a given source file turns into a sea of red Xs despite SBT compiling the code just fine. Often an ./eclipse -clean is the only way to right the ship.
Perhaps IntelliJ provides a different experience (although I've heard there are issues with the Scala plugin there as well).
So I'm not buying this argument from Adams that the PHP iteration is necessasrily faster. It definitely used to be that way, but I think other languages have caught up.
We are churning out complete web services two or three at a time in 6 person shop, every month or so. We weren't as productive in PHP. Maybe that's just us getting better as programmers, but I also think it has a little to do with the bugs and other things caused by the lack of static typing and various language quirks.
Plus, Scala has access to the entire Java ecosystem, which is arguably as or more mature than the PHP ecosystem. So I don't spend a lot of time reinventing the wheel, as the Facebook engineers have done with their custom framework.