News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court Rules That Yelp Must Unmask the Identities of Seven... by pmiller2 on Sunday January 12, 2014 @10:19PM (#7048704)
I don't see how that helps people whose carpets have been held "hostage."
Re:Court Rules That Yelp Must Unmask the Identities of Seven... by bertil on Sunday January 12, 2014 @11:43PM (#7048960)
It won't, and that's not the point here.

A judge has been asked to prove that seven commentators are actually clients of the service — otherwise, said comments were slander. He or she can't ignore that; more importantly, that accusation is almost systematic from service providers who accuse Yelp of slandering them, presumably with non-existant users, and then racketing them to dismiss said comment (in actually, pay to chose which comment to put first). Having the receipt might help clear common issues: the user got the name of the restaurant wrong, the interaction happened before the owner changed, it happened ‘that night’, etc.

This is far from an isolated case: all services from the distributed economy (eBay, AirBnB, Blablacar, etc.) have to handle trust and find appropriate mechanism. There has been cases of good-grade racketing on eBay; AirBnB has proven fairly good so far; BlablaCar name itself is a great example of a non-binary rating. Hence the discussion.

If users of that service want to get their good back, a small claims court seems more appropriate than a Hacker News thread.

Re:Court Rules That Yelp Must Unmask the Identities of Seven... by pmiller2 on Monday January 13, 2014 @03:05AM (#7049440)
No, the point is that those people can't prove they were customers by presenting a receipt. Should that mean they get to get sued and have to spend time, effort, and money defending themselves in court?