News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by seanmcdirmid on Sunday January 12, 2014 @07:56PM (#7048216)
> but many people probably think that Twitter is the most active micro-blogging service in the world

It is. Weibo doesn't do well outside of China, it is not international like Twitter is.

> that PayPal is the only really huge payments service

From the perspective of a non-China resident, that is definitely true.

> Amazon and eBay are the major players in ecommerce

Ditto. Though Taobao is trying to become a major international player.

> For any service you can think of in the US, there's one in China that might be even bigger.

Except the services in the US are mostly international. The services in China are almost always limited to just China. The fact that UnionPay is the largest ATM network in the world (by users...almost all in mainland China) doesn't mean diddly when I visit the Netherlands or India where my ATM card is USELESS.

China has decided they can lock out international internet services (via the GFW) and build their own isolated network. Internally, it is huge, but the isolation cuts both ways.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by turingbook on Sunday January 12, 2014 @08:14PM (#7048278)
GFW did do something but can not explain everything. China Internet companies have their own advantages: local leaders can make agile decisions to local market need, employees are more motivated, the management structure is flatter... For example, ecommerce was not regulated much here, but Amazon and eBay were beat heavily by local competitors.
Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by seanmcdirmid on Sunday January 12, 2014 @08:40PM (#7048349)
This is quite ridiculous. If the GFW didn't block Facebook or Twitter, they would have market shares in the mainland similar to those that they have in Hong Kong and Taiwan.

Chinese Internet companies are still quite Confucian in their organization with meaningless titles and lots of seniority plays; they are hardly flatter than the typical American internet company. Many of them still rely on freaking time cards for their tech workers, for crying out loud!

Amazon does well in China; we order things from them all the time (even rice).

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by turingbook on Monday January 13, 2014 @04:44AM (#7049666)
>If the GFW didn't block Facebook or Twitter, they would have market shares in the mainland similar to those that they have in Hong Kong and Taiwan.

They would have some market shares but not very much, just like Amazon.com is a small player and one of few foreign survivors in China although I also like its service. In the past, MSN messenger, Yahoo, Google, eBay, MySpace, to name a few, all failed in competition with local China players. That is not by chance.

As for management, the biggest problem of foreign companies is that decisions especially critical ones are always made in USA, which is normally slow and ignorant. And founders and top guys in China companies(still very young at their 20s or 30s) like Pony Ma at Tencent and Robin Li at Baidu can directly attention the specifics of key products or services even at pixel level.

Who will win?

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 13, 2014 @06:01AM (#7049918)
> They would have some market shares but not very much, just like Amazon.com is a small player and one of few foreign survivors in China although I also like its service. In the past, MSN messenger, Yahoo, Google, eBay, MySpace, to name a few, all failed in competition with local China players.

Then why doesn't the CCP just unblock twitter, facebook, g+, and so on? I have a hard time to believe its for reasons of porn (easy to find in the GFW) or subversion (also easy to find in the GFW). And how do you explain Facebook's success in HK and Taiwan? People outside of China just being afraid of Chinese services? That could make sense...

> As for management, the biggest problem of foreign companies is that decisions especially critical ones are always made in USA, which is normally slow and ignorant.

The biggest problem is that we can't play very well at all in the market. First, foreign companies have to follow all the rules very strictly: local companies have the ability to be "flexible" until (and if!) the government cracks down; they also don't have to deal with the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA). The lawyers of most foreign companies also won't go near ambiguous China privacy and secrecy laws with a 100 ft. pole, meaning anything that deals with data or communication inside the GFW absolutely requires a local partner (say TomTom).

I have friends who worked or are working for local companies, and they tell stories of extreme shadiness. These are not even small no-name companies, but companies you've probably heard of before; I won't name names since the foreign community that works in these companies is very small. They work very hard, but the market is cut throat and they do what they need to do to survive.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by turingbook on Monday January 13, 2014 @06:17PM (#7054274)
>Then why doesn't the CCP just unblock twitter, facebook, g+, and so on?

It seems that you believe China government helped local players succeed. That is not true in general. The private local Internet companies are not the government's child. They are mostly controlled by foreign investors.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 13, 2014 @06:43PM (#7054410)
The CCP likes companies they can control, whether there are foreign investors or not. This is especially important since the rule of law isn't so developed in China and often directives go through non-legal channels, which Google couldn't deal with while Baidu has no problem with it. Both of these companies are listed on the Nasdaq, but one is controlled by Americans and the other by Chinese.
Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by turingbook on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:41AM (#7055733)
If CCP wanted to control the Internet, it should help Renmin, Xinhua, Wangfujing or China Mobile to be market leaders, not Baidu, Sina, Taobao or Tencent.

Actually except Baidu vs. Google, you can not think out other examples the government made big impact. The other competitions in Internet between Yahoo vs. Sina, eBay/Amazon vs. Taobao/JD, MSN messenger vs. QQ, are all good counter-examples.

Foreign companies can not adapt to needs from local users. That is the key. The market is the king to decide the fates of Internet companies and products in China generally. Others are important but not critical.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:24AM (#7055843)
> Foreign companies can not adapt to needs from local users. That is the key. The market is the king to decide the fates of Internet companies and products in China generally. Others are important but not critical.

And yet, all those companies do very well in HK, Singapore, Taiwan; aren't they Chinese also? Why is the mainland market so different from other smaller Chinese markets? They also do well in Indonesia, Thailand, Nepal, India...while the Chinese companies...they are just going to be stuck being local.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by turingbook on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:52PM (#7058905)
I do not know a lot about the things outside China. But Japan is another example that many foreign Internet companies struggle. Maybe we could add Russia. These markets have something common.

HK and Taiwan are too small market to have strong enough local team.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:08PM (#7061009)
Google and Facebook still do very well in Japan. Yahoo does also, obviously. Russia is no where as near as closed as China is, and many international companies do well there. China is quite unique.

Supposedly, Chinese internet companies should do well in HK/Taiwan, these markets are definitely open to them, but since they don't have to compete with international brands in the mainland, they are not competitive enough to operate very well on the outside. Besides, any service run inside China is taboo outside of China (and Americans think the NSA is bad...).