News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by dengnan on Sunday January 12, 2014 @07:38PM (#7048157)
To those who are interested in startups in China:

I personally know some people who worked on start ups in China. From their experience, I see no hope for start ups without connection with government. I will show you some facts and some real examples here.

Here are some basic facts:

Chinese government controls Internet content tightly. Note that it is not the same level as NSA's surveillance. NSA's surveillance is bad. But it won't, or rarely, (directly) change/delete the content. The Chinese government, on the other hand, can even shut down a whole datacenter without telling the administrator with no reason --- By "no reason", I mean absolutely no explanation.

I had a blog and I know the service provider personally (It was a website hosting blogs like myspace). My blog was a high ranked one on their website. I posted some content discussing related to democracy/free speech in China and the whole website was down for a day. My friend received a call from network management department after they cut the network. They forced my friend to delete my blog entirely (the whole blog including posts for years.)

Chinese website was required to control any content on their website, otherwise, like the case I mentioned above, their website might be shutdown before telling you the reason. This is especially true for small startups.

Here is another example: during the early age of twitter (around 2008.), there were several startups in China trying to make a copycat of twitter in China. We call it micro-blogs and there are companies like hainei, jiwai, etc. working on twitter-like services. As we all know, content on such websites generated very fast. Much faster than traditional blogs. This makes the filtering work extremely hard --- those websites has to identify contents which are "politically incorrect" and delete them before any government officer found them (And yes, we DO have government employees who are dedicated to found those contents and report it to their higher authorities.) Such filtering work is impossible for a startup with tens of employees -- They used some filtering algorithms but people can always use other words to bypass the filter. Such micro-blogs (or twitter-like services) grows so fast with too much "unwanted" content, that finally, by mid-May 2009, they were all shut down by the government for half a year. Imagine a startup running without a live service for half a year, you know how hard it would be.

During this time, large companies with government connections like sina, tencent, 163, ect, prepared their own micro-blog services and finally put it on line. Such companies has large teams who dedicated themselves to filter content on their websites. Nowadays, the micro-blogs are only run by those large companies and none of the startups survived.

I told these stories to those who do not familiar with Chinese Internet Policy and intent to do some startups in China. My advise is: do not run a content-based startups, otherwise you can hardly afford the cost of filtering the users' contents.

EDIT 1: changed some spellings and expressions.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by turingbook on Sunday January 12, 2014 @09:08PM (#7048451)
The stories you told are true but just tell one side of things.

On the other side, nowadays big companies such as Sina, Tencent, 163(Netease formally) you mentioned and Alibaba, Baidu, among others all grew up from small startups without government connections at the beginning.

And more and more new startups are founded everyday, some of which will be very successful, just as in USA. Qunar and 58.com are the newest ones with market value of more than 3 bilion dollars.

As for content-based business, there are still room for startups. We have seen several new technology news websites emerging these days. Even user-generated content business is possible if you avoid risky political discussion.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by WaterSponge on Sunday January 12, 2014 @07:46PM (#7048178)
So I think the world understands that doing business in china requires some special attention.

Despite all of that they are doing business in China. Serious dollars are being made and value being delivered to millions of users. We should want in on that or to at least have some understanding of how its being done in comparison to US/EU.

Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by seanmcdirmid on Sunday January 12, 2014 @08:01PM (#7048230)
You assume the Chinese market is free, which it is not. The barriers are high, and the government just doesn't want you getting in on the business.
Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by 1stop on Sunday January 12, 2014 @08:59PM (#7048425)
The last 30 years of Chinese economic growth (fuelled by foreign investment) disagrees with you.
Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by seanmcdirmid on Sunday January 12, 2014 @09:46PM (#7048591)
The Chinese are totally ok with taking our foreign money (or HK, Taiwan), they just don't want us to get rich off of it (at least very easily). The economy is still very protectionist and you have to be very careful when investing here; many industries are just completely off limits and even those that are left open are often hobbled by protectionist ownership rules (e.g. 51% must be owned by a well connected Chinese company).
Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by itchitawa on Sunday January 12, 2014 @08:37PM (#7048339)
MegaUpload, Silk Road shut down by US government. Piracy, drugs, child porn, online gambling. These are things Americans feel are OK to silence. Inciting violence (they have deadly anti-government riots), destabilizing the government. These are things Chinese feel are OK to silence. Different stokes for different folks. In either case you need enough staff to monitor for such illegal content.
Re:What The Chinese Tech Industry Is Like by dengnan on Sunday January 12, 2014 @08:57PM (#7048417)
Well. According to Ugly duckling theorem[0], any classification algorithm is biased. It's not about finding an unbiased system, it's about which side should be preferred by the system. Specific to the discussion about network surveillance, it's about which group of people should be protected: The mass majority or the minor elite/politicians.

If we have limited resources to control speech, I would argue that those resources should be mainly used on to government/politicians. Because they have much more power over the others.

Piracy, drugs, child porn, online gambling, blocking these things online is supposedly by the people through direct or indirect votes. (NOTE: I'm not talking about the facts in the U.S. or any country. I'm talking about how things should work.) The things blocked in China, on the other hand, are only decided by the government, not the people.

> In either case you need enough staff to monitor for such illegal content.

Until there's a clear definition of "illegal". As I mentioned, Chinese government can shutdown any website at their will, without any warranty. No need to say that the government is not voted by the people, which by itself is illegal.

0. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ugly_duckling_theorem

EDIT 1: add another graph to clarify my point.