Re:Show HN: NullPass, a stateless password manager written i...
by adammacleod on Sunday January 12, 2014 @07:54PM
(#7048207)
No, not really. I do like having the length concatenated inside as well, as this provides a unique password for different lengths (useful to quickly visually identify if a password looks 'right').
Is there any reason why HMAC would be better than my current implementation? I have had a read over the article and it seems that straight SHA512 should have similar cryptographic strength.
Thanks for your input!
Re:Show HN: NullPass, a stateless password manager written i...
by pwg on Sunday January 12, 2014 @09:10PM
(#7048458)
Read the "Design Principles" section more carefully. Simple concatenation suffers from several different attack vectors.
Re:Show HN: NullPass, a stateless password manager written i...
by adammacleod on Monday January 13, 2014 @12:19AM
(#7049059)
Thank you.
I am concerned about changing the algorithm at this point in case anyone has already used it. I don't think there are any serious concerns but will report back if I find any (after taking some more time). Of course if anyone knows this stuff very well I'd be very eager for some feedback!
Re:Show HN: NullPass, a stateless password manager written i...
by pwg on Monday January 13, 2014 @08:04AM
(#7050272)
> Of course if anyone knows this stuff very well I'd be very eager for some feedback!
Exactly why you should be considering changing the algorithm.
http://happybearsoftware.com/you-are-dangerously-bad-at-cryp...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hash-based_message_authenticati...