News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medium is Winning by strict9 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @02:24PM (#7043439)
I wish I could read that article, but full-width sentences and tiny typeface are painful. The beautiful large typography and layout of Medium is one reason it's winning, despite its sometimes laughable content.
Re:Medium is Winning by cliveowen on Saturday January 11, 2014 @03:07PM (#7043563)
Not only it's completely unreadable, but it's way too long. I bet I could make the same point in a couple paragraphs, tops.

People who show no hesitation in throwing a wall of text at other people show how much they really care about the reader's time.

Re:Medium is Winning by andreaja on Saturday January 11, 2014 @04:55PM (#7043928)
Yeah, well, that's just, like, your opinion, man.

Not everyone writes with you in mind as their ideal reader. Some people write for themselves and publish to keep themselves honest, though I don't presume to know what OP's motives and goals are in this case.

Re:Medium is Winning by mkr-hn on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:18PM (#7044000)
It's still not a bad idea for the OP to know conventions/standards in case (s)he decides to write something for the public. The OP's HN profile does point to the blog, which tells me other people were in mind during the writing process.
Re:Medium is Winning by lmm on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:24PM (#7044015)
If I put a note in my profile that I like full-width text (like HN) and think the font size (larger than HN) is reasonable, do you think that'll stop me getting these same comments every time I post something to HN?
Re:Medium is Winning by strict9 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @07:06PM (#7044425)
Since you're posting your articles to HN, you obviously want people to read what you write. If you want more people to read your writing, then consider making it more accessible and easier on the eyes.

People exist with visual disabilities and giant walls of text in layouts such as yours might as well be a magic eye puzzle.

Yes, you like it and can do what you want, but you're throwing sand in the eyes of people you want to read your stuff.

Re:Medium is Winning by lmm on Sunday January 12, 2014 @04:29AM (#7045618)
HN itself has wider text and smaller fonts than my site. So it should be in line with what the HN readership (taken as a whole) likes. (Yes, I see more complaints than compliments, but that's always to be expected)

Visual disabilities are an argument for having a font size consistent with the rest of the web and a site where browser zoom works, not for making your text larger than the rest of the web.

Re:Medium is Winning by herval on Sunday January 12, 2014 @05:42AM (#7045713)
If you always see more complaints than compliments, why not trying to change and see if the audience reacts better?
Re:Medium is Winning by lmm on Sunday January 12, 2014 @06:02AM (#7045731)
Because I see the same thing for any site posted to HN, no matter what the design is. So I don't think it's evidence of anything.
Re:Medium is Winning by pavlov on Saturday January 11, 2014 @02:54PM (#7043530)
In Chrome, the "Zoom In" command is in the View menu.

Zoomed in by two increments (125%), the font size and margins of the article become reasonably close to the Medium gold standard. Hopefully this may help you finish reading the article.</mildsarcasm>

Re:Medium is Winning by strict9 on Saturday January 11, 2014 @03:04PM (#7043549)
I already browse at 125%. It takes 200% to get to a comfortable readable level, and that doesn't address full width sentences. Too much effort for a wall of text.

Typography matters.

Re:Medium is Winning by lmm on Saturday January 11, 2014 @03:30PM (#7043630)
If you don't like reading text at that width, why's your browser that width? Surely you don't want to have 2/3 of your screen blank white.
Re:Medium is Winning by dovel on Saturday January 11, 2014 @04:36PM (#7043849)
Or you could try designing a better site if you want people to read your content. Trust me, I'm sure we can all live without it. Line length should never be that long. Also, many sites are not just one column of text so there are many reasons I would have my browser this size.
Re:Medium is Winning by mkr-hn on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:00PM (#7043944)
You can put a lot of stuff in the other 2/3. Stuff that readers will enjoy. I keep a top post widget on my own blog. People seem to like it, and I know I like having easy access to more stuff from a writer whose words I didn't mind reading. The aversion to criticism you've shown in this thread makes me think I won't want to see anything else from you, so maybe it's for the better in your case.
Re:Medium is Winning by lmm on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:20PM (#7044005)
> You can put a lot of stuff in the other 2/3. Stuff that readers will enjoy. I keep a top post widget on my own blog. People seem to like it, and I know I like having easy access to more stuff from a writer whose words I didn't mind reading

I found that kind of stuff offputting. It was one of the things I really noticed when thinking about why I preferred to read on Medium: there are a few social things at the end and those very subtle comment things, but for most of the time while one's reading it really is 2/3 blank white. (I sometimes use clearly to make medium wider - didn't want to complicate the post by mentioning that).

> The aversion to criticism you've shown in this thread makes me think I won't want to see anything else from you, so maybe it's for the better in your case.

Sorry to hear that. I was pleasantly surprised the post made the front page, pleased to see 7 comments... and then it turned out none of them were engaging with my words, they were all just complaining about the presentation (and worse, they're all the same complaints, and ones I've seen before. I don't know what I'm supposed to do about this (given that I'm happy with the design and disagree with those complaints) - I doubt people would read a FAQ).

Which I guess is what I get for writing a post on the subject of presentation, but it was still pretty disappointing.

Re:Medium is Winning by mkr-hn on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:22PM (#7044012)
Presentation is everything. It's not just a cliche they put in business books and MBA lectures. Screen-width text is fine if you only want it read by people with the patience to use third party tools for an unknown author.
Re:Medium is Winning by lmm on Saturday January 11, 2014 @05:29PM (#7044034)
I prefer full-width; I find it more readable, and I wish more sites would use it. Given that, it would feel hypocritical to not use full-width text on my own site.
Re:Medium is Winning by djur on Saturday January 11, 2014 @03:45PM (#7043669)
Many websites assume you have at least 1024x768. Trying to browse at less than that without some kind of intrusive style munger is awkward.
Re:Medium is Winning by Kluny on Saturday January 11, 2014 @03:50PM (#7043688)
I also made the window half-size to reduce the line length... ugh.