Re:In defense of BSD licenses (response to Zed Shaw)
by boucher on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @05:04PM
(#704610)
You're confused about who the user is in this discussion.
The user is the end user of software, not the developer who is using your code. GPL protects the rights of end users, no matter how many developers sit in between the original code and the end user.
In other words, as an end user, if I'm using a GPL program, I know that I can access the source code and fix anything I need to or change anything that needs changing.
To be as specific as possible, in what I described, you don't count as a developer until you actually take your changes and give them to someone else, so distributor may be a more accurate term.
Re:In defense of BSD licenses (response to Zed Shaw)
by jmillikin on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @02:12PM
(#704248)
Software under the BSD license may be given to a user without providing the corresponding source code, effectively preventing the user (or an agent authorized by the user) from modifying their copy of the software.
What rights do software users benefit from with GPL licensed software that they do not with BSD licensed software?
You seem to make the point a couple of times that the GPL is more free and gives more rights to users.. could you elaborate on that as, to how I see it currently, little is more free than the BSD license except the public domain. The GPL places all sorts of restrictions on users if they choose to modify the software.