The man used two physical calibration devices on the monitor. I think that means he values color reproduction much higher than the average buyer.
CNet compared the 50inch model to a 50 inch 720p plasma, and came to the conclusion that the plasma was a better tv. The review was more focused on using it as a television, but it appears that product is low quality.
http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-33199_7-57599449-221/budget-tv-...
Do you have an ax to grind, or is this just typical HN pedantry?
The reviews on Amazon for this display is a solid 4.0 from 200+ reviews -- hardly the shite quality you seem to be suggesting. Given that the thesis of the article is that this would be great for programmers (i.e. not designers or the color obsessed), the fervor to which you're arguing the point seems misplaced.