You should offer a default set of recommended modules similar to the Acquia distribution. Let people customize as needed but get them going in the right direction by setting up a suite of the most common, well-supported modules typically needed for a functional Drupal site.
Great idea! Every package that is built is saved for immediate download or installation when other users choose the same add-ons. So, for every permutation, there is a corresponding "app version". It was my hope that the popular versions would bubble to the top and develop a following. Based on your comment, I think I need to make a "popular versions" box and display it prominently on the app details page. Thanks!
"There are an insane amount of add-ons on the page after you select the app...They should be categorized, or something."
Maybe there should be less per page, so the user isn't initially overwhelmed. You can drastically reduce the number of results by using the search box at the top. Also, you can use the "filter & sort" box on the right to filter by category. Thanks for taking the time to respond.