Re:Stackoverflow podcast recipe
by discojesus on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @12:01PM
(#703944)
Not to mention the fact that at least one of the criticisms in the article is a total strawman. Joel never said that unit testing is absurd; he said that 100% coverage (and to a slightly lesser extent, unit testing of criteria where tests can not be sufficiently automated (like GUI layouts)) are a waste of time, and that resources could be allocated much more efficiently.
Yeah, agreed. That criticism would really sting... if they didn't have a functional and (IMHO) successful website to point at.
Very true that the podcasts are little more than entertainment. However, I don't think there is a problem with unit testing within the community. In fact, there is probably very little real unit testing going on at all. Probably why everyone speaks so profoundly about everything needing it.
And as for the example of unit testing, it is refreshing to see successful programmers question the gospel of the unit testing crowd...judging by the writings from that community, something like SO would be virtually impossible without serious unit tests or TDD, because as you know, projects are just absolute chaos without massive unit tests in place.