News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by ErrantX on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @04:56AM (#703338)
As much as he makes good and bad points I think some of the commentary here is unfair; I think Zed is just explaining why he wants to use GPL license from now on.

As someone who has been "burned" on some minor pieces of code I agree with him somewhat. If, for example, I laid down some pretty useful code and open sourced it - then a startup came along, used it to bootleg their code and made millions I'd be pretty upset. That's not what it was open sourced for (because no one benefits from their millions).

Perhaps no money required but it is nice for companies in those situations to say "yeh and we built it on the awesome XXXXX (link to site)". Because that means more people can find something that is useful to them.

Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by zmimon on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @07:20AM (#703462)
I'm sorry, if you released the software under a liberal open source license then you weren't "burned". I don't get what it is that makes people release software under licenses that say "do whatever you want with my code" and then suddenly get all self-righteous when someone actually does that. Be pleased and flattered your software is being used - if that wasn't your original motivation then you chose the wrong license to begin with.
Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by ErrantX on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @07:58AM (#703510)
Hence the quote marks.

I didnt hugely mind the use of my code. It just sucked that after beign asked they refused to push fixes and improvements back into the public branch. That's takign advantage of the permissive license IMO :)

>Be pleased and flattered your software is being used

No one is suggesting this isnt the case :) it's possible to be flattered by some and frustrated by others (indeed if they refuse to add code to the "pot" I dont consider their use very flattering....)

Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by e4m on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @08:53AM (#703567)
"If, for example, I laid down some pretty useful code and open sourced it - then a startup came along, used it to bootleg their code and made millions I'd be pretty upset."

I wonder if Linus is upset with RedHat?

Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by ErrantX on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @09:32AM (#703620)
red hat contributes to kernel development ;)
Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by loumf on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @03:11PM (#704379)
Red Hat gave away a lot of shares to Linux/Unix contributors. Here's an article from Eric Raymond about shares he got from VA Linux, but it mentions Red Hat doing this as well http://www.linuxtoday.com/news_story.php3?ltsn=1999-12-10-00...
Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by gaius on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @08:11AM (#705543)
That is actually an article about what a tossbag ESR is.
Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by codemonkey on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @01:39PM (#704173)
RedHat also gave him some fat stock options, just to say thanks.
Re:Zed Shaw: Why I (A/L)GPL by Tichy on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @03:35AM (#705334)
What was it open sourced for then?