News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Light Table is now open source by belorn on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:43PM (#7033083)
1: A license that do not allow circumvention of property law is friendly to the business market. As such, your claim that it would prioritize "something" over "essential elements of software freedom" are wrong.

2: Not allowing circumvention of property law is neither promotion or restriction of freedom. It has the same purpose such as anti-theft laws. business markets depend on property law, and could not operate without it. However, selecting enforcement of property law can be exploited in the market, and a segregation between those who exploit and those who don't then happens.

3: anti-theft laws and "software freedom" are not directly related. This is where the confusion comes from.

> It would be more accurate to say, for what it defines as "User Products", that the GPLv3 actively encourages device renters to circumvent the property rights of devices' owners, and bars device owners from having the technical tools to prevent that.

You seem to imply that manufacturer are the device owner after they have sold the device. Here we must come to a disagreement, as I follow the classic view that a trade results in a change in ownership. The financial transaction causes the manufacturer to assign ownership of a specific device over to the buyer in exchange for money. The new owner of the device is thus no longer the manufacturer, but the person who paid money for it.

Maybe the wikipedia article, or a dictonary would help you here. Renting is not the same as a trade. I can see how you might get those two words confused, but really, they are not the same thing.

If device manufacturers want lease out devices rather then trade them, they can likely do so without having comply with the requirements in the GPLv3 license. Leasing out devices is commonly not viewed as distribution (case law lacking).

Re:Light Table is now open source by dragonwriter on Thursday January 09, 2014 @06:07PM (#7033922)
> You seem to imply that manufacturer are the device owner after they have sold the device.

No, that's irrelevant.

> If device manufacturers want lease out devices rather then trade them, they can likely do so without having comply with the requirements in the GPLv3 license.

The anti-tivoization clause specifically applies to transfer of a "User Product" with the right to possession and use of the device either permanently (sale) or for a period of time (rental).