Re:Torrents hidden in PNG images
by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @02:56AM
(#703238)
So it will be difficult to detect visually, but isn't this rather trivial to find algorithmically? Not that I know much about cryptoanalysis, but it seems to me that this is a very weak form of steganography.
It's reasonably hard to detect if just the least significant bit is random, but if you do the last three significant bits you don't even need an algorithm--you can see the jagged, broken histogram.
Re:Torrents hidden in PNG images
by stcredzero on Monday July 13, 2009 @11:20PM
(#703035)
How about a filter that takes ordinary images, but turns them into low-light photos? Or just turns them into grainy photos? The grain can then be shifted around for purposes of the encoding.
I was actually thinking about this last night as a means of hiding text or pictures.
I would just round each pixel's R, G, and B values off to either even or odd. Even stands for 0, odd for 1. That gives you three bits per pixel and hopefully would be very hard to detect visually with, for example, a nature photograph.
Then you just encode another image in 8-tone grayscale at the same size. That's what I was after, I haven't done the calculation for how large an image you'd need to encode real files.
Spore actually does this with the PNG files from the "Sporepedia". You can actually import an image of the creature you want from the Sporepedia webpage and the playable 3D creature will appear in the game! http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=703719
Photos (especially of poorly lit environments) should be perfect. They're very grainy by nature, so it will be especially difficult to trace where the data resides. Because you can hide so much data in the image, you can get very creative with where and how you do the encoding.