News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @10:33PM (#7028585)
> someone's software freedom is impeded

Nobody's freedom is impeded. They didn't have the freedom to modify the code in the first place, since they didn't have the source code. Nothing they could do before has been taken away.

It's really intellectually dishonest to use this freedom and morality rhetoric when you're actually talking about compelling people to give away something they have created.

Not that I think it's conceptually a bad idea. I see nothing wrong with the idea of the GPL as a concept. A contract that says 'if you use this software, you agree to also give away any code you base on it' seems fine.

But I see no reason not to just call it 'permanenrly malleable' software or something like that.

It's the faulty rhetoric around freedom that is presented as a moral crusade that is a problem.

Re:Light Table is now open source by TuringTest on Thursday January 09, 2014 @09:54AM (#7030750)
There's no intellectual dishonesty here, just a semantic mismatch. You're using the negative definition of freedom, which is the lack of explicit restrictions on behavior; the logic you expose only holds under that particular school of thought.

The GPL is instead defined on the tradition of positive liberty, which defines freedom as the number of options freely available to each person to choose. There's a very real risk of those being reduced by permissive licenses, as you can no longer ignore network effects, as negative freedom (being defined over individual atomic actions) does.

History shows us that if you allow open source code to be relicensed as proprietary, the competitive advantage of companies building and selling products with enhanced features tend to displace the original project, which gets abandoned. This happened to Unix, to Mac OS X, and is now happening to Android. If this continues for an extended time, the whole ecosystem evolves and the old software becomes unusable, greatly reducing the total options that users can effectively perform - not by an legal or coercive restriction, but because of pragmatic impossibility. There are permissive projects where this doesn't happen (at least for a while) because of the economic incentives of remaining close to the free+open project, but the risk is always there.

What good is the permission to run the original, abandoned version of a software project if all the available hardware has been locked and is uncapable of running it, and it's impossible to modify it to support the modern functions that are available in the proprietary platform and required for any productive usage? Those are very real threaths, and the GPL was designed to combat them (as a reaction to the first time they happened on a large scale). Avoiding this "reduced total available options" scenario is what GPL projects call freedom, not "reducing the number of restrictions" definition that you use. Not a problem of rhetoric, but of chosen vocabulary.

Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Saturday January 11, 2014 @02:15PM (#7043410)
I don't use a 'reducing number of restrictions' definition. That's a straw man that I was responding to.

I also don't accept "history shows us" as establishing some law of nature when the history we're talking about is a couple of decades.

I think the abandoning of ecosystems can just as easily be explained by them being based on inadequate foundations, than by a mythical horde of developers somehow being prevented from working on them. Usually systems are abandoned because of a lack of economic incentive, after all the displacement you describe can only happen if proprietary development produces enhancements more efficiently than open source. Witness the failure of the Linux desktop.

I think 'greatly reducing the total options that users can effectively perform' is a statement that needs much more qualification. To me, that's a function of design, extensibility, and how much leverage a system provides, and is independent of whether the source is available or not. Extending by forking is a last resort.

Nevertheless, I do respect the hypothesis that a GPL style open system provides an important counterbalance to proprietary systems.

What I do not support is the dishonest use of language and morality to further it.

If you are using positive freedom, then there is much more to be gained through improvements in software design - e.g. along the lines of Alan Kay's FONC - to increase leverage - than through ideology.

Re:Light Table is now open source by TuringTest on Monday January 13, 2014 @01:35PM (#7052411)
We are talking of UNIX here. It has not been abandoned as an unsuccessful ecosystem, it has been rewritten away from the legalistic minefield that its permissive licensing allowed it to be; and that ''did'' prevent developers from freely working on it, and business from freely deploying it despite its open source origins. The history we've watched is that of Linux and GNU on the server (UNIX didn't have any strong desktop environment to begin with); and the UNIX wars span nearly 40 years, with Linux being the last half of it.

I still fail to see what is it that you call dishonest use of language. If freely talking of one's perspective and goals is dishonest, then all ideologies are.

Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @01:15PM (#7064978)
Except that FreeBSD is just as freely deployable without the need for the GPL, so it is not the GPL that causes this property to come about.

The dishonest use of language is the misappropriation of the word 'freedom', and the moralizing around what is essentially a business problem. But, if you are claiming to be an ideologue, then fair enough.

In which case, I'd love to hear more about how that ideology translates into a better future economic future for software developers. To me it seems to just translate into greater dependence on powerful corporations.

Re:Light Table is now open source by superuser2 on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @10:50PM (#7028629)
Someone switches to your product, or a new user chooses your product over the open-source alternative. The proportion of people who can modify their software decreases. That is a decrease in software freedom.

Not necessarily a bad thing (your product might be legitimately better), but it is a decrease in software freedom.

Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @11:07PM (#7028691)
Freedom hasn't decreased at all. Those people have exactly the same choices as before. They can use the open-source alternative if they want to change the code. Merely 'using' a closed source product doesn't prohibit them from doing that.
Re:Light Table is now open source by superuser2 on Thursday January 09, 2014 @12:28AM (#7028945)
Lots of people who would otherwise be Linux or BSD users instead use OSX. Consequently, they are not free to modify their operating systems where (had it not been for Apple) they would have been. Their freedom has been reduced voluntarily, but it has been reduced.

Forking FreeBSD is not remotely the same thing as forking OSX and you can't "just use the open-source alternative if they want to change the source code" of OSX.

Re:Light Table is now open source by dsuth on Thursday January 09, 2014 @01:14AM (#7029087)
Their freedom has not been reduced, as they are still free to choose an alternate, FOSS operating system if they prefer. Instead, they have access to more options than they otherwise would have, because it's highly unlikely that Apple would have expended so much effort in improving their OS, which is a competitive advantage for them, if they were forced to turn over all of that work to anyone who wanted it.

I really don't like the idea of licences which compel their users to act in a certain way. Freedom cuts both ways.

Re:Light Table is now open source by superuser2 on Thursday January 09, 2014 @01:44AM (#7029147)
Software freedom has a specific meaning which necessarily encompasses freedom to study and modify the software you're running.

OSX users do not have this freedom. Hence, prevalence of OSX reduces software freedom. Ability to choose between OSX and alternatives is something but it is not software freedom.

Re:Light Table is now open source by dragonwriter on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:49PM (#7040824)
> OSX users do not have this freedom. Hence, prevalence of OSX reduces software freedom.

This doesn't follow. Like most arguments about proprietary software reducing, rather than not providing, software freedom, it seems to rest on the assumption that if proprietary software did not exist, it would be replaced use-for-use with Free software, that is, that license models have no impact on the creation or distribution of software.

Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:46PM (#7040809)
That's why this rhetoric is dishonest. It's the use of this specialist meaning of the word freedom in a way which is opposite to it's conventional meaning.

If you stop using this misleading word, the whole GPL thing looks more reasonable, but also less like a moral crusade.

Re:Light Table is now open source by superuser2 on Friday January 10, 2014 @09:54PM (#7041281)
Not really. Freedom to modify your software is a kind of freedom which cannot exist when you are exercising your freedom to use proprietary software. Like many things in our world, it's a tradeoff.
Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Saturday January 11, 2014 @11:56AM (#7042998)
This is doublespeak. You are conflating the words freedom and choice.
Re:Light Table is now open source by dsuth on Thursday January 09, 2014 @04:22PM (#7033357)
That seems like a narrow definition of software freedom , but in that case I'd argue that the utility gained from software freedom is not as valuable to users as the incentive gained by developers for being able to distribute their software under a more permissive licence.
Re:Light Table is now open source by dllthomas on Friday January 10, 2014 @11:54AM (#7037627)
There's never a need to distribute software under a more permissive license except enabling distribution of software under less permissive licenses.
Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Sunday January 12, 2014 @01:53PM (#7046971)
That's a very important need.
Re:Light Table is now open source by dllthomas on Sunday January 12, 2014 @01:58PM (#7046999)
You're going to need to elaborate, for discussion to be useful.
Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Sunday January 12, 2014 @06:36PM (#7047984)
So that people can make money out of software and incentivize its development.
Re:Light Table is now open source by dllthomas on Monday January 13, 2014 @10:03AM (#7050907)
If such an amount of software is being produced under the GPL that inability to borrow from that pool of work is significantly hampering proprietary development, I'd say it's plainly false that this is the only way to incentivize software development and quite possibly the case that it's not the best way.
Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @01:09PM (#7064932)
So your absolutist position about "there's never a need..." translates into a dislike for paid software as a business model.

What business models for software do you prefer, and why?

Re:Light Table is now open source by dllthomas on Thursday January 16, 2014 @09:00AM (#7069374)
You removed my qualification, attributed the result to me, and called it an absolute position. I would not make, with confidence, the statement "There is never a need to release under a more permissive license." To get there from what I said, you would need "There is never a need to distribute under a less permissive license." I do think this need is exaggerated, but labeling that "absolutist" strikes me as odd.

I have no objection to "paid software" as a business model, because the term is too broad. Paying someone to add a feature I want to a GPL project and release the result is, I think, not something anyone would object to. I have objection to "proprietary software" as a business model, because it collapses the value that the software can provide; I am not convinced that this objection is sufficient to say that proprietary software is always the wrong choice. I have more objection to proprietary software where, having paid, I cannot see the source and make changes (or pay others to make changes).

There are a number of alternatives for funding development of mass-market software that are more compatible with copyleft licenses (donations, threshold pledge models, consulting) and I'm currently working on an innovative project in this space.

Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:49PM (#7040827)
Freedom has still not been reduced. This so-called gain in freedom of OSX users to modify the code has come at the expense of a corresponding loss of freedom of Apple to choose whether to release their code or not.
Re:Light Table is now open source by belorn on Thursday January 09, 2014 @07:02AM (#7029966)
I make software, and I do not want people who use it, share it, or modify it to be under the threat of being sued. Legal violence is to me is near equal to physical violence, and thus a moral issue.

I do also not care if the legal violence happened because of changes an other developer did on my work. Just because they added something does not give them the right to use what I made into a legal weapon.

Re:Light Table is now open source by gress on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:51PM (#7040835)
It's hard to know whether you are supporting or rejecting the GPL.