News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Light Table is now open source by barbs on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:22PM (#7027897)
Just to clarify - it's not illegal to sell GPL'd code, so long as you provide the source with the binary.

In fact, this is exactly what happened with Dosbox Turbo (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.fishstix.d...). Dosbox is licensed under GPL, but here it's still being sold on Google Play. The author, fishstix, will send you the source if you've paid for the binary. This is completely legal.

https://sites.google.com/site/dosboxturbo/gpl

There were a couple of good discussions on this on SlashDot and VOGONS:

http://yro.slashdot.org/story/12/12/09/1721200/ask-slashdot-...

http://www.vogons.org/viewtopic.php?t=34107

Re:Light Table is now open source by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:51PM (#7028008)
> Just to clarify - it's not illegal to sell GPL'd code, so long as you provide the source with the binary.

This is, however, not much of a business model, because the customers get the code under a license that allows them to redistribute it. Your first customer could buy the binary and then start selling it on Google Play themselves or give it away to everyone. Selling GPL code is pretty much just syntactic sugar over asking for donations.

Re:Light Table is now open source by davedx on Thursday January 09, 2014 @02:18AM (#7029251)
You underestimate the friction there I think.

Conversely you could also argue "it's not much of a business model to sell apps on app stores, because Chinese companies will copy and resell your app".

Re:Light Table is now open source by girvo on Thursday January 09, 2014 @04:38AM (#7029546)
In my experience, dealing with GPL software that was sold for $5k+ -- no one ever bothered doing so. And this was a PHP app, so it's not like distribution would be difficult for the would be pirate, nor was there any copy protection. It's just, for those sorts of products, no one ever bothered. I thought it was interesting.
Re:Light Table is now open source by lsaferite on Thursday January 09, 2014 @02:23PM (#7032553)
Could you really classify someone who has a GPL enforced legal right to distribute your code a 'pirate' though?
Re:Light Table is now open source by dllthomas on Thursday January 09, 2014 @06:58PM (#7034118)
I'm not sure you can really classify someone who has no right to distribute your code a 'pirate' - real pirates kill people. Your point stands, though, to be sure.
Re:Light Table is now open source by moocowduckquack on Saturday January 11, 2014 @11:38AM (#7042950)
Real pirates often try as hard as possible not to kill people. Crew are usually worth more money alive. If you do kill someone, often you get fined by your captain and have to continue piracy to work off the debt.
Re:Light Table is now open source by dllthomas on Sunday January 12, 2014 @11:54AM (#7046474)
So real pirates and music "pirates" share that it's not their goal to kill people. The latter still kill far fewer people, and the former still engage in much more violence.
Re:Light Table is now open source by moocowduckquack on Sunday January 12, 2014 @12:14PM (#7046547)
Sorry, I'm just being horribly pedantic, but I suspect that music pirates kill far more people than real pirates, purely because so many people are technically music pirates, wheras the real pirates are very few in number and are also quite likely to be pirating the latest sea-shanties, so there is a lot of overlap.
Re:Light Table is now open source by dllthomas on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @11:32AM (#7064235)
Sure, to be more precise... "real pirates are disproportionately more likely to kill people by virtue of being real pirates; the same is not true of music pirates."
Re:Light Table is now open source by girvo on Friday January 10, 2014 @05:04AM (#7035934)
Eh, I couldn't be bothered thinking of the right word, but I'm sure you knew what I meant :)
Re:Light Table is now open source by lsaferite on Saturday January 11, 2014 @12:06PM (#7043020)
Well, I could guess your sentiment even though I thought it was wrong.

It just made me think of those stupid 'you wouldn't steal a car' ads before movies and I thought I'd point out that they have every legal right to re-sell GPL code if they want.

Re:Light Table is now open source by Intermernet on Thursday January 09, 2014 @05:08AM (#7029637)
My feeling is that the fairness effect comes into play strongly with open source distribution models. People are willing to play fairly (i.e. not re-distribute source code that's probably only a google search away anyway) when the author does the same.

Frans De Waal demonstrates an experiment with Capuchin Monkeys showing this effect in action.

http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v425/n6955/abs/nature01...

http://youtu.be/lKhAd0Tyny0

Re:Light Table is now open source by barbs on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @09:05PM (#7028291)
True. It's not illegal, but it's not a particularly good business model!
Re:Light Table is now open source by moocowduckquack on Saturday January 11, 2014 @11:35AM (#7042939)
The QP framework does this through dual licencing, so they sell a commercial version of exactly the same code that they also release under GPL.

http://www.state-machine.com/licensing/faq.php

Re:Light Table is now open source by dllthomas on Thursday January 09, 2014 @07:00PM (#7034123)
You can only strictly expect to sell the first copy. That's not a problem if selling the first copy covers your costs (contract work), but that can sometimes be a business model.
Re:Light Table is now open source by ivanca on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:30PM (#7027927)
What happens if your software haves 2 binaries that talk to each other and one of them contains the GPL'd code; can I just give the code for that one or do I have to release the source of both?
Re:Light Table is now open source by barbs on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:35PM (#7027945)
It's a bit of a grey area, but the FAQ states that so long as they're kept separate, and they communicate "at arms length", they should be ok:

https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl-faq.html#GPLInProprietarySy...

http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/110380/call-g...

Disclaimer: IANAL

Re:Light Table is now open source by belorn on Thursday January 09, 2014 @06:23AM (#7029846)
Sooner or later, laws will get interpreted by a judge/jury. You question is equal to asking at what point a work should be considered a derivative work.

The answer is sadly quite blurry, and country specific. US law say something like: "A “derivative work” is a work based upon one or more preexisting works, such as ... abridgment, condensation, or any other form in which a work may be recast, transformed, or adapted."

What would a judge say about two separate programs that talk to each other? A lot of people and companies has their opinion about it, but there is not much of case law in existence. All one can say is that the GPL author does not consider IPC level of communication to trigger a derivative work.