Re:Ask HN: If Politicians were selected by Random Lotto?
by dllthomas on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:31PM
(#7027631)
"1: Is what we have now working, e.g. is there still homelessness, and poverty in America?"
You presume that there could not be homelessness and poverty in the optimal system. I'm not sure that's guaranteed.
"2: If our system is already failed, how does trying something new that may fail, hurt anything?"
You can always fail harder.
Mind you, I'm in favor of a basic income and there are some interesting things about this idea (though I don't think I favor it); I'm just skeptical of your rhetoric.
You presume that there could not be homelessness and poverty in the optimal system. I'm not sure that's guaranteed.
"2: If our system is already failed, how does trying something new that may fail, hurt anything?"
You can always fail harder.
Mind you, I'm in favor of a basic income and there are some interesting things about this idea (though I don't think I favor it); I'm just skeptical of your rhetoric.