Re:Light Table is now open source
by sillysaurus2 on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:03PM
(#7027070)
You're preaching to the choir, my friend. I think the GPL is great.
I also think the MIT license is great, or at the very least that people who use it shouldn't be vilified. As I mentioned elsewhere, vilifying the MIT license is counterproductive to our mutual goal of seeing less proprietary software. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7026368
The fact that some code is licensed with the GPL is in no way detrimental to anybody. If the person who had written the GPL code had instead made the code completely closed source, "game programmers" would have been in a situation that would can only be the same, or worse. They would still have to write their own code, and wouldn't have even the choice of building upon the free software and making it free to everyone else.
Open source developers are under no obligation to do your work for you, or to make your life easier. That some choose to do so is fantastic. To expect everyone to give away their code with no form of compensation is silly (even if that compensation is simply paying it forward).
And there's always the third option... pay someone for an alternate license to the code. Do you really dig Lighttable, and want to incorporate it in your closed source videogame? Pay the developer enough money that he'll license it to you without any of the GPL clauses.