News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: If Politicians were selected by Random Lotto? by PaulHoule on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @03:33PM (#7026376)
I've advocated this for a long time.

The big advantage is that it would put an end to corruption. If you tried to corrupt a member of the political class you might get a polite "no thank you" at best. If you tried to corrupt average Americans you might have some who would say yes, but you'd have 1/3 who would call the cops, punch you in the face, pull a gun, or otherwise do something that would make it way too risky.

Re:Ask HN: If Politicians were selected by Random Lotto? by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:10PM (#7026656)
> The big advantage is that it would put an end to corruption.

More likely it would move the locus of corruption (as well as the locus of power) from the actual members to the professional staff, on whom randomly-selected members would be more dependent on -- and less skilled in controlling/evaluating -- than professional politicians.

(To a certain extent, term limits do this with the locus of power, as well.)

Re:Ask HN: If Politicians were selected by Random Lotto? by notahacker on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @04:27PM (#7026812)
What makes you think people are less likely to be corrupted by power and large financial incentives if they don't have to convince the electorate they have principles?
Re:Ask HN: If Politicians were selected by Random Lotto? by PaulHoule on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:05PM (#7027515)
It works the opposite of how you say.

The first rule of being a "respectable" person is that you have to respect other "respectable" people.

For instance, you have to respect Bernard Madoff because Bernard Madoff is respectable.

What this means is you can safely feel out a respectable person to see if he is corruptable or not. If you picked average people, very dangerous things might happen at a 30% or so probability.