Strictness and abuse are completely unrelated. To imply that to require pupils obey rules is abuse is mind boggling.
The article is deliberately connecting the two (e.g. in the first paragraph), which is why I comment on it.
Re:Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results
by mseebach on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:29AM
(#7023067)
7th paragraph:
> Now I'm not calling for abuse; I'd be the first to complain if a teacher called my kids names
The fact that the 7th paragraph says "Now I'm not calling for..." implies that the connection was made in the first 6 paragraphs, yes.
Teachers are not successful because they are strict (it's not directly causative): they are successful because they are in command of the classroom.
You can gain better command of a classroom through fear of abuse, yes, but this is not a method we should aspire to.