News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results by danso on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @06:25AM (#7022870)
Back in high school, our journalism teacher was legendary for his scathing, but usually humorous criticism. And yet the Friday after we published the newspaper, critique day, was one of the most-eagerly anticipated days, as he would alternate between complementing people and then ripping others apart for not just things like punctuation and sentence structure, but higher-level failures such as failing to interview key people and providing fair coverage. A lot of students cried and even though he's still a teacher today, I can't imagine that the discipline and excellence he demanded would go over well today.

But it worked, the newspaper and yearbook were consistently the best in the country. It wasn't just a niche club, they were actually credit classes that filled up. It was actually cool* to be on staff, despite how seriously it was taken (though thinking back, my main contribution was installing NES emulators on all the machines, so it couldn't have been that serious)...

Edit: to clarify, I can't recall if he "ripped" into people for spelling errors/grammatical mistakes, though he'd point them out in a funny way and move on. But boy, if you did something like a professional breach...such as interview your same best friend for an article that you did last month, he might go off on it. Sloppy writing (burying the lede) was also jumped on, but in a constructive way. But that kind of constructive criticism...singling someone out in class...I didn't see it much out of high school.

Re:Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results by mattlutze on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:37AM (#7023101)
I think there must be a psychological equivalent to the feeling that your kids' sports teams "play to their opponents."

I would not be surprised for research to demonstrate that children perform to the expectations given them, particularly when those expectations are clear and consistent. In fact, most people thrive in environments where they understand the rules, rewards, penalties, and where those structures are evenly and consistently enforced.

Re:Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results by pmorici on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:47AM (#7023132)
There is a good documentary about schools that defy the odds in traditionally bad areas of inner cities called "Waiting for Superman"[0] one of the things they talk about is having consistently high expectations for _every_ student.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waiting_for_%22Superman%22

Re:Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results by DanBC on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:45AM (#7023126)
The environment you describe doesn't include "ripping people a new one" for spelling errors.

Correcting mistakes is one thing but insulting people making errors is probably harmful not helpful.

Re:Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results by mattlutze on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:48AM (#7036329)
My strictest, and most beneficial, professor was so hard on my writing that, when I finally produced something up to his expectations, his feedback comment casually wondered whether I had plagiarized it.

It's cliche because there's some merit: he wasn't our friend, but had an incredibly positive effect on our abilities in the subject.

I've no strong opinion whether public shaming is good or bad with spelling errors. Maybe the hypersensitivity we've culturally adopted to the emotional state of children biases our perception of the impact of such things.

Re:Why Tough Teachers Get Good Results by harvestmoon on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @10:56AM (#7024233)
My former High School produces a newspaper, which is distributed to a location that I visit often. I enjoy reading it, oddly enough, in part because there are a variety of issues with the writing that I like getting worked up about.