News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by copx on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @11:52AM (#7018248)
I grew up watching Star Trek: TNG and that episode is something to remember indeed. It makes a strong rational and moral case against torture. While modern American TV shows do indeed do the opposite.

I think I know the reason for this. Gene Roddenberry was a WW2 veteran i.e. the Geneva Conventions had a personal relevance to him. In the wars of the past you had to assume that many of your own guys would be captured by the enemy.. and that you might end up being one of them. In that scenario a strong international condemnation of torture suddenly looks way more appealing. In contrast, America's modern "wars" (I do not think these one-sided affairs deserve that name) do not lead to a noticeable number of American POWs. And you no longer have to worry about being drafted yourself either.

I think the foundation of the acceptance of torture in contemporary America is the firm conviction of the supporters that they will never be at the receiving end.

This type of thinking is unfortunately widespread among humans everywhere. It is never moral and often unwise to support a system you would not support if you did not have a favorable position within it.

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by rayiner on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @12:24PM (#7018431)
Your explanation is probably part of it, but there's are lots of social factors in play. Gene Roddenberry was a member of the greatest generation. It was in a lot of ways a much more idealistic time in American culture than today.

One of the empirically observable facts is that faith in public institutions is a lot lower today than it was back then. I think this phenomenon cuts in the opposite direction compared to what a lot of people on HN would suppose. When people have less faith in the system, they have less faith that the system will protect them, and are more willing to embrace characters that will act outside the system to get the job done. Hence the popularity of the Jack Bauer character: the guy who ignores taboos against torture or procedural limitations like warrants in order to get the job done and save the day.

That's starkly different to the world conceived of in Star Trek. Star Trek is a world where government (the Federation) is morally virtuous, and institutional rules like the "Prime Directive" are to be followed rather than broken.

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by WalterBright on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @01:52PM (#7019037)
Captain Kirk violated the Prime Directive in practically every episode.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by dkuntz2 on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @02:47PM (#7019403)
The Prime Directive wasn't mentioned until the end of the first season, and it wasn't defined until the end of the second season.

And, provided someone previously broke the Prime Directive, inadvertently or not, Starfleet personnel are permitted to directly intervene and ignore the Prime Directive to minimize the harm caused. And most cases where Kirk "violates" the Prime Directive, someone else already interfered, meaning no violation occurred.

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by humanrebar on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @12:46PM (#7018590)
> One of the empirically observable facts is that faith in public institutions is a lot lower today than it was back then.

I wonder if Gene Roddenberry would have had different opinions of public institutions if he grew up after the collapse of the USSR.

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:00AM (#7022641)
Actually, those of us born around the time the USSR collapsed are more in favor of public institutions: we've seen what happens in their absence.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by mattlutze on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @07:51AM (#7023146)
Is this your personal ethos being projected across our entire generation, or are you referring to research that shows, when compared against public opinion of similarly aged people over the last many generations, we favor public institutions?
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @08:46AM (#7023383)
I'm referring to research. My personal opinions are very left-wing even for Gen Y.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by mattlutze on Friday January 10, 2014 @07:43AM (#7036318)
Could you link it? I'm interested to see that, because most of my circles are very much not in that camp.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by morganherlocker on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @12:14PM (#7018372)
> It is never moral and often unwise to support a system you would not support if you did not have a favorable position within it.

Is this an intentional reference to John Rawls' concept of the 'veil of ignorance' laid out in Theory of Justice? If not, you would definitely enjoy the ideas in the book.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veil_of_ignorance

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by npsimons on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @05:07PM (#7020335)
Exactly what I was reminded of; Rawl's theory of justice, paraphrased: the only just system/rules are ones you wouldn't have a problem being on either side of.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by snogglethorpe on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @09:13PM (#7021253)
Isn't it just Kant's "categorical imperative"...?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Categorical_imperative

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by derleth on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @09:47PM (#7021364)
The categorical imperative is strictly weaker: It's possible to use the veil of ignorance to argue against positions nobody is insisting must be made universal.

For example, "In this house, you always clean up": The categorical imperative only works to argue against this if you try to find a way to apply it to every household; the veil of ignorance works simply by forcing the members of the household to be ignorant about who 'you' refers to.

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by dkuntz2 on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @01:43PM (#7018958)
Small note, but Roddenberry was dead before The Chain of Command went into preproduction. I'm also not sure that was an episode he would have let through considering he was against the militarization of Star Trek.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by salient on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @01:42PM (#7018952)
> In contrast, America's modern "wars" (I do not think these one-sided affairs deserve that name)

That's a great point. America doesn't do wars anymore. They do conquests. And the American public at large seems perfectly fine with it (or they wouldn't allow it).

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by DougWebb on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @02:53PM (#7019454)
I wouldn't say that the American public at large seems perfectly fine with it (or they wouldn't allow it.) That's a very broad brush you're painting with. A large proportion, probably a majority, don't like what's being done with our military. We tried to get Bush Jr out of office after his first term, and that was a very close election with just as much evidence of vote tampering as the his first election. Obama was overwhelmingly elected because everything thought he would do things differently and restore our standing in the world, but that's turned out not to be the case. His reelection was much closer, and he probably only won because his opponents were so weak.

After all these years, I think the American public has largely given up on their votes making any difference whatsoever; President, Senate, House of Representatives, they mostly all do whatever their financiers want once they're elected, public opinion be damned.

Anyone want to come in and liberate us from our corrupt government? (I was going to say tyrannical, but I don't want to devalue that word; we're not there yet.)

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @05:14AM (#7022684)
There's been a joke for a few years: the USA needs to invade America, bringing freedom, providing democracy, constructing infrastructure, and creating jobs.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by aragot on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @06:58PM (#7020858)
I like your analysis, DougWebb, I deeply like it.

Please note it's important you American citizen communicate on your opinion as much as you can, beyond your borders. Even if you see no immediate effect, it will benefit you.

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by DougWebb on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @05:04PM (#7020315)
Too many typos in that; too late to edit it. Oh well. I need to proofread better before I submit a reply.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by rayiner on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @02:32PM (#7019310)
What the U.S. does is to use military force to preserve the international status quo. E.g. if we go into an oil rich state like Iraq, we don't just take the oil, we just ensure that it continues to be sold in the market as usual. This isn't "war" but it's not "conquest" either.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by code_duck on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @03:48PM (#7019795)
The thing is that the status quo is in the favor of the US, and they ensured that the oil continued to be sold to the US.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by rayiner on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @04:08PM (#7019931)
Sure, the status quo is in favor of the U.S., and we ensured that oil continued to be sold to the U.S., but it's also in favor of France and Germany and the U.K. and Australia, etc, and we ensured that oil continued to be sold to those countries too. It doesn't really make sense to call that "conquest."
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by PavlovsCat on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @09:52PM (#7021379)
Since when does conquest have to benefit just one party to be called conquest? If Russia and China split the US amongst themselves, would you call it conquest?
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by rayiner on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @09:23AM (#7023584)
Did we split Iraq amongst the U.S., France, Germany, the U.K., Canada, Australia, etc? When many beneficiaries are involved, a military action seems less like conquest and more like an attempt to maintain a certain balance of powers.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by PavlovsCat on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @10:47AM (#7024165)
"maintain a certain balance of powers" and "conquest" are not mutually exclusive.

"many" really just means "more than one", but okay: if 50 nations invaded and split up the US, would that be conquest?

Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by code_duck on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @04:12PM (#7019967)
Sounds like conquest by NATO vs solely the United States.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by trothoun on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @04:08PM (#7019934)
The other thing is, it's not just the US that benefits from the status quo. Lots of allies get to ride on their coattails.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by code_duck on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @04:14PM (#7019976)
Isn't that generally what goes along with allying yourself with someone - the parties agree to do mutually beneficial acts and let each other benefit from each other's actions? I don't see how benefiting your allies makes an action less self serving.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by mrobot on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @11:02PM (#7021596)
Don't forget that we can also just ignore it or have it hidden from us. In that case it happens without us being for or against it.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by memracom on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @06:20PM (#7020714)
And the use of torture in America's modern wars has led to a great amount of lost goodwill in the world, not to mention the military failures on the ground.
Re:The Rise and Rise of Television Torture by w_t_payne on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @01:11PM (#7018748)
Do unto others...

How quickly morality fades ....