News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by analog31 on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @12:05AM (#7015710)
This is completely beside the point of the article, but I work for a company that makes fairly large precision equipment. A potential service nightmare is when the customer moves the equipment and screws it up. A lot of this equipment is designed to only be installed by the supplier, due to the amount of documentation and training that would be needed for customer installation. And something like a big CNC may have some fairly detailed site and installation requirements.

Maybe the GPS is so it can receive targeted ads. "Customers who machined this part also ordered..." ;-)

Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by alan_cx on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @12:17AM (#7015760)
Well, I know it took me ages to get my half decent hobby lathe (Myford) perfectly setup for my own hobby use, which is possibly the least accurate form of machining out there. (No, Im not making bombs, I'm making parts for silly, RC usually, models!!!) So, I can well see high end CNC machines having to be very precisely set up, and I can also see that being a fairly long, PITA job. Frankly, if we are talking maintenance on CNC machines worth $100k, or whatever, I'd want some lock down and historic data. Does make sense.

So, I think where contracts are in place, they have every right to lock the machine down. Which is probably part of any contract. But, putting aside what I was saying about nukes, I can't see why, if there is no contract, an owner has to have his machine bricked if (s)he wants to move it. Again, unless these machines are specifically restricted by law or international treaty type things.

Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by vacri on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @01:50AM (#7016037)
Reminds me of a story from the other end of the skill ladder - as a student, I had a short-term job in a hosiery factory, ostensibly to help move a couple of very heavy machines around, with the rest of the time doing stockroom work. The Day came, the crane operator came along and told us to keep clear, and we didn't lay a finger on the machinery. Us hired meat just went back to the stockroom, fine by us.

Incidentally, if you're looking for easy stockroom work, a hosiery factory has no heavy lifting...

Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by farginay on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @07:55AM (#7016991)
If that's all they were concerned with they could just use GPS readings to invalidate the service agreement rather than switching the machine off.

In any case, I wish that Congress would step up and put law around the issue of whether one can "sell" things with restricted use. E-books, for instance, are really leased rather than sold. A sane legal system would give teeth to that legal distinction.

Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by DennisP on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @10:16AM (#7017699)
In this case they're claiming that Congress required them to restrict the use.
Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @03:51AM (#7016325)
Yeah that sounds like a valid reason, too. These things work with millimeter accuracy; jolt them and the accuracy may be off. Position them just slightly off-level and they might be off.
Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by srbucsh on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @06:08AM (#7016636)
You're off by 3 to 5 orders of magnitude depending on the specifications of the machine and kind of work it's doing. Isolating these machines from outside vibrations as well as canceling out their own internal harmonics is no small engineering feat and typically involves pouring a concrete slab custom for the setup. Beyond keeping up export restrictions and avoiding bad installations I can see it as a way of avoiding warranty fraud with user error or crane accidents.
Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by VLM on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @11:06AM (#7017970)
Oh no not that meme again.

The reason why machinists who know only a little about machining demand you must level a lathe bed or it won't work, insist on that old wives tale, is because a simple "cheap" way to prove the lathe bed isn't twisted is to simply plop a precision level on various parts of the lathe bed and various directions... If the lathe bed is level everywhere, it must be a flat plane (well, plus or minus curvature of the earth over 100 foot monsters, obviously)

Obviously machine tools don't have to be level; otherwise you'd never see them on ships, deep sea platforms, mobile "back of truck" repair trucks, things like that. They have other, somewhat more laborious or expensive ways to determine and shim flatness.

If you made the flimsiest imaginable 3-d printer, then sag might be relevant... however you're talking about beasts of a machine that can drop 10-100 rotating HP and not twist or distort... anything less than 45 degrees isn't going to matter.

Now one problem I have personally seen is some CNC gear has what boils down to a conveyor belt that streams out metal chips. So if you mounted it 10 degrees tilted, you might have chips not fall on the conveyor belt. This is usually a simple adjustment to various guards / guides / baffles. Its not a very serious concern.

As a cross industry comparison, learned helplessness is a common feature in IT/CS land, where your average luser is extremely proud to not know anything about his computer that he uses 8 hours per day, and no one expects him to know anything either. However in machine world its somewhat unusual to have IT-like levels of learned helplessness, so the average machinist dude can quite easily handle shimming a lathe or adjusting tilts and such.

Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by superuser2 on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @04:41PM (#7020167)
Is it possible that tools meant for ships/oil rigs/trucks are built differently from those that have the luxury of sitting on a stationary floor?
Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by elemeno on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @06:04PM (#7020630)
They're almost certainly not expected to work to anything near the level of precision that these sorts of high-end CNC machines do - judging by the comments in this thread, you're talking about micrometer level precision. They are to 'machine-tools' what your home server is to google's data centres.
Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by analog31 on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @10:03PM (#7021408)
Point well taken about the cutting force probably dwarfing external forces imposed by minor tilting.
Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by walshemj on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @11:23AM (#7018077)
Your quiet right though I think you meant micrometer not mili.

Machine tools do need a nice really really flat surface to work on when you working to micrometer or single thou's of tolerance even the smallest tilt in the x or y plane is unacceptable - you probably also want a very stable temp environment.

ps I never thought id have the chance to use the old unit "thou's" in a hn comment

Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by starky on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @02:00AM (#7022152)
Your comment implies that micrometers and thous aren't an order of magnitude different. Regardless of which one you are talking about small tilts are not going to make a big difference. As long as everything is lined up properly within the machine then you aren't going to have a problem. Hell, even if it is a horrible, cheap, backlash ridden machine it is quite possible to machine something down to 1 thou tolerance provided you are careful and know a few tricks. I'm not even trained as a machinist and I have done that without too much trouble.
Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by walshemj on Wednesday January 08, 2014 @08:23AM (#7023284)
you said "These things work with millimeter accuracy" what I said was I think you meant Micrometer which is 3 orders of mag different.

I just added thou's is as a courtesy to this in the USA who still use imperial

Re:High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturer... by vdm on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @06:27AM (#7016702)