Re:Loan Monitor Is Accused of Ruthless Tactics on Student Debt
by jcampbell1 on Thursday January 02, 2014 @09:27PM
(#7003824)
> It sounds like there's an incredible amount of work that goes into calculating those plans
It is a simple calculation. 15% of Discretionary Income. DI is calculated as AGI minus 150% of the federal poverty line. For instance, if someone is single and makes $35k per year, their monthly payment is capped at: (35-11.5×1.5)×.15/12 -> $222 per month.
What is complicated is when people say they can't make the income based repayments because of a hardship. That is when all the counting meals and extra bedrooms happens.
Cole is right, and 'undue hardship' is highly subjective. However, as it stands only "hundreds try" to discharge their student loan debt through bankruptcy, and unknown how many succeed.
Undue hardship sounds like something we should be managing towards an overall level of 0.1% not 0.0% as they are now. I think the problem is that you can't achieve that on a case-by-case basis. Anything but impossible standards would blow past 0.1% in a heartbeat. I think you would need some sort of quota / ranking system and current law doesn't allow that.
What the story didn't talk [enough] about is how the income-based plans actually work. It sounds like there's an incredible amount of work that goes into calculating those plans (counting number of meals at McDonalds?). I don't know why that would be necessary. I assume you would just target a percentage of adjusted gross income. The whole point of the loan is to increase AGI so if AGI is systemically too low to repay the loans, the problem is with the economy or the educational system, not the individual.