This seems a bit delusional. I don't think it's controversial to say that Apple's biggest differentiators exist at higher levels than kernel space. I'd go so far as to say that anyone who claims that Apple's success is rooted in XNU and that the same could not have been done with Linux or *BSD at the lowest layer and all other pieces being equal does not understand what a kernel is.
But this is not a suggestion for them to scrap it, necessarily. As I said in some other comments on this thread, I think the real reason is that they had people that knew their existing kernel well, and don't see a need to replace it.
See my comment up thread about Jordan Hubbard's plans.
xnu is also a monolithic kernel, just with some nice message-passing primitives. Think Mach 2.5.
Edit: ok, I just figured out my source of confusion. IOKit allows userspace drivers, which can crash without resulting in panic.