Re:Builder Blames Navy as Brand-New Warship Disintegrates (2...
by nknighthb on Thursday January 02, 2014 @12:02AM
(#6998293)
I'm nowhere near old enough to remember the F-16's development, but it sure looks like recent programs have suffered a great deal from bikeshedding and trying to be everything to everyone.
Look at some of the F-16's rough contemporaries: The F-14, F-15, F/A-18, A-6, and A-10.
Despite a fair bit of flexibility and overlap in mission capabilities, especially after post-debut tweaking, these are all different planes designed with different goals in mind.
Now think about the F-35/JSF. It's one program that's basically trying to replace everything leftover from the cold war. That seems like a big red flag.
It seems like something similar is going on in the LCS program. They're explicitly supposed to be "flexible" and "modular" -- aka "be ALL THE THINGS!" -- and "replace" a variety of more special-purpose ships.
Swiss army knives are handy, but I'm not going to try building a house with one.
Look at some of the F-16's rough contemporaries: The F-14, F-15, F/A-18, A-6, and A-10.
Despite a fair bit of flexibility and overlap in mission capabilities, especially after post-debut tweaking, these are all different planes designed with different goals in mind.
Now think about the F-35/JSF. It's one program that's basically trying to replace everything leftover from the cold war. That seems like a big red flag.
It seems like something similar is going on in the LCS program. They're explicitly supposed to be "flexible" and "modular" -- aka "be ALL THE THINGS!" -- and "replace" a variety of more special-purpose ships.
Swiss army knives are handy, but I'm not going to try building a house with one.