News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Builder Blames Navy as Brand-New Warship Disintegrates (2... by nl on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @11:50PM (#6998253)
Not an expert on this in any way, but I did enough chemistry to know that galvanic corrosion is very well known, especially on ships.

I suspect that the protection system was cut from the ship in the understanding that the Navy would instead do ongoing maintenance to stop it (not exactly sure what that maintenance would look like - maybe sacrificial anodes instead of some kind of electrical system? - but stay with me...)

Doing that would cut the capital cost of the ships (ie, what is reported as "how much it cost") and move that cost to an ongoing operational budget.

I'm guessing the Navy was under pressure to squeeze the budget, so this looked like a good way to do it.

But it sounds like the Navy also had their operational budget cut to the point where they didn't do the ongoing maintenance? Or maybe they just forgot about it..

Anyway, I suspect that's what the real story would look like.

Re:Builder Blames Navy as Brand-New Warship Disintegrates (2... by pdonis on Thursday January 02, 2014 @02:04AM (#6998554)
Sacrificial anodes are a type of cathodic protection system (the simplest and most common type). They're not a substitute for it.

Anyway, you can't do "ongoing maintenance" to substitute for cathodic protection. Galvanic corrosion is going to happen continuously as long as the ship is in the water; the only question is what corrodes, the protection system (the sacrificial anodes, in the simplest case) or the hull and other parts of the ship. If there's no protection system, what does that leave to corrode?

Re:Builder Blames Navy as Brand-New Warship Disintegrates (2... by nl on Thursday January 02, 2014 @03:24AM (#6998736)
I'm thinking the original plan was some non-sacrificial anode system, and that was replaced by sacrificial anodes (requiring maintance, which was never done).

If there is no protection then the hull corrodes, as this story shows...

Re:Builder Blames Navy as Brand-New Warship Disintegrates (2... by pdonis on Thursday January 02, 2014 @10:54AM (#7000150)
I'm thinking the original plan was some non-sacrificial anode system, and that was replaced by sacrificial anodes (requiring maintance, which was never done).

This would be consistent with the manufacturer's claim that the Navy did not properly maintain the ships. However, a sacrificial anode system is a type of corrosion protection, so it wouldn't be correct to say that no corrosion protection was installed on the ships. Of course, it's quite possible that the journalists writing this story don't understand the technical details themselves and so are not correctly describing the situation.

Re:Builder Blames Navy as Brand-New Warship Disintegrates (2... by BrandonMarc on Thursday January 02, 2014 @12:47AM (#6998407)
I was under the impression that sacrificial anodes, turning the ship's hull itself into a cathode, were standard equipment installed in all oceangoing ships (Navy or otherwise).

I'm surprised it's not the case.