Yes, since one of his main points was that the free market failed in this case. Even allowing that he imprecisely described a distorted market pre-ACA, he clearly prefers a differently-distorted market post-ACA without much justification about why this time it will work out in the end. Anecdotal evidence about quoted premiums (not even considering out-of-pocket expenses going forward) is not convincing.
> Historical background is often very useful in a policy essay.
He cherry-picks his historical background then. A better background would discuss the employer-provided healthcare mess, the financial insolvency and increasing costs for Medicare and Medicaid, and the perverse incentives of related programs like Social Security Disability. Even if going into the Republican/Democrat history, it's a limited view. He left out more piecemeal initiatives like Medicare Part D, health insurance co-ops, and subsidized high-risk pools.
So I disagree that the limited historical background the author provides is value-added. On the contrary, that talking point detracts from his thesis.
> Broken promises with no legal recourse" would be a pretty good characterization of pre-ACA health insurance, by the author's account. Why would you expect the ACA to be any worse in this regard?
You can sue an insurance company if it advertises one thing and then changes the deal after you sign up. People, the author included, are not keeping their plans and doctors. I was pointing out that this bait-and-switch will happen in either system, but companies can be held civilly liable for making bad promises.
> So, again, what evidence is there that this problem will be more acute under the ACA?
What evidence is there that it will be less acute? To me the convincing prima facia case is that ACA will at least be more of the same in this regard.
> The fact that the author feels strongly about a certain political issue cannot be used to rebut his argument about that issue.
I think you're missing my point. I actually thought the first half of the piece was interesting. But by the time I reached the end of the piece, it seemed to me that the beginning of the piece was just a roundabout setup to his final point about how ACA is great and cathartic to the author.
> The author offers technical arguments concerning a matter of public policy.
Some. But he also offer personal anecdotes about how he felt guilty that a family friend couldn't get insurance. And many of his arguments are appeals to fairness more than they are descriptions of incentives and outcomes.
> He then states a political opinion which follows logically from those technical arguments.
That's the thing. It's a political opinion, so it doesn't follow logically. Even his logic is suspect. There are matters of fact that aren't considered (employer-provided healthcare, healthcare costs for state governments, healthcare subsidies, price regulations, policies changing between states). There are arguments that aren't, strictly speaking, logical (association fallacies, false dichotomies, straw men).
A logical conclusion would be more modest, technical, and have fewer exclamation points.
He very precisely describes how parts of the ACA address different modes of market failure he observed. The existing-condition regulations prevent the bandwagon effect and corporate freeloading (only covering healthy people). The individual mandate prevents individual freeloading (retaining fallback benefits without paying into the system).
See, health care markets have a long history of failing (or at the very least failing to deliver value in comparison to their single-payer counterparts). We already know "undistorted" markets where care providers sell directly to patients don't work for emergency services (you have consent issues with unconscious people AND the nearest hospital is always an effective monopoly and can price gouge accordingly). The "undistorted" market already failed to deliver value. Health insurance companies tried to fix the problem but it turned out that deceiving customers into buying shit plans was a better business strategy than legitimate innovation. Again, the "undistorted" market already failed to deliver value.
The US strategy amounts to trying different permutations of regulations until we find one that allows the free-market to work. So far, it has been a whack-a-mole experiment that costs ~$1.5T and >40,000 lives per year (in comparison to single-payer systems). When does it end? Do you really want to pay 2x for care today in order to gamble on the possibility that eventually the correct combination of regulations will be discovered that creates an efficient free-market system?
> companies can be held civilly liable for making bad promises.
Then why were they getting away with it?
His observations of what the companies were getting away with contradict your claim that the courts were able to keep them in check. The ACA attempts to keep them in check by making it harder for them to dupe users in the first place (that's what the standardized silver/gold/platinum plans are all about).
> it seemed to me that the beginning of the piece was just a roundabout setup to his final point about how ACA is great
He uses evidence to support his thesis. How does that detract from his argument?
> [In addition to technical arguments,] he also offer personal anecdotes
Anecdotal evidence doesn't invalidate his technical arguments. Also, the support it provides his arguments can only be ignored in the face of better evidence. Do you have any?
> many of his arguments are appeals to fairness more than they are descriptions of incentives and outcomes.
Outcomes are judged by fairness. The "technical arguments" you just referred to describe incentives. The hell are you complaining about?
> It's a political opinion, so it doesn't follow logically.
One of the funny things about logic is that it knows its own limits (Godel Incompleteness). Unless you have a strict logical rebuttal, why should I discard his argument for yours (which, as far as I can tell, is based on faith rather than observations, experience, anecdotes, and analysis)?
> A logical conclusion would be more modest, technical, and have fewer exclamation points.
A logical conclusion that suffices to guide policy decisions doesn't exist. We must get over ourselves and make do with the best that we have.
Look, if you're actually interested in scholarly analysis of this kind of thing, here's a good starting place: http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single-payer-resources
I haven't found a paper-aggregation of comparable quality for the "other side" of the argument (I'm familiar with the 1989 Heritage Foundation memo, not much else). If you could reciprocate with such an aggregation, I'd be much obliged.
His main point is, roughly: 1) a variety of factors, including fear and antiselection, made for a broken health insurance market prior to the ACA, and 2) the ACA has substantially mitigated some of those problems.
> A quick example is the obvious contradiction in the following quotes from the blog:
The author is using the term in subtly different ways in different contexts. Not the best rhetoric, I admit. Yet, does his failure to define or consistently use the term "free market" undermine his thesis? I would venture not, but I'd be open to a counterargument. Otherwise this objection seems like just so much caviling.
> Later the post pulls out some talking points about Mitt Romney and some conservative think tanks, which are definitely relevant if you are trying to score political points instead of discussing healthcare policy.
The Heritage Foundation and Mitt Romney both played significant roles in the history of healthcare in the US. Historical background is often very useful in a policy essay. That appears to be the reason the author mentioned them. You're free to disagree with the author's characterization of their roles. But you didn't.
> The closing section that glosses over the big problems with centralized planning systems (broken promises with no legal recourse, implementation issues caused by politics interfering with sound decision making) and finishes with enthusiastic exclamation points:
"Broken promises with no legal recourse" would be a pretty good characterization of pre-ACA health insurance, by the author's account. Why would you expect the ACA to be any worse in this regard?
My experience has been that private companies very often fall victim to "implementation issues caused by politics interfering with sound decision making." I've seen symptoms of that malady in every private health insurance company with which I've dealt. So, again, what evidence is there that this problem will be more acute under the ACA?
> It seems like political cheerleading to me, but maybe I'm missing something.
Yes, I believe you did. The article included much substantive information about the inner workings of health insurance companies and the economic forces that drive their behaviors. Indeed, there is much more of this sort of thing than there is political cheerleading, the latter being confined to the final section.
The presence of some political cheerleading does not indicate the absence of a valid argument. The fact that the author feels strongly about a certain political issue cannot be used to rebut his argument about that issue.
> To summarize this piece, it seems like this guy felt guilty for working at an insurance company, but now he feels better because the he politically supports the ACA, which he feels is going pretty well. Is there an apolitical thesis for this blog post that I'm missing? Why was it written if not to express a political position?
The author offers technical arguments concerning a matter of public policy. He then states a political opinion which follows logically from those technical arguments. There's nothing invalid about this pattern of reasoning or argumentation.