It also has secondary effects in employment markets:
* employers should not be encouraged to replace full-time workers with part-time workers because of health insurance costs
* employees shouldn't be making decisions about careers and jobs based on what health insurance costs will be
* the actual compensation levels between jobs is harder to evaluate since health benefits can be a huge chunk of compensation these days
To critics of the ACA, the relevant question is, who or what is in an effective position to put downward pricing pressure on hospitals? Because to date, it has clearly not been individuals or insurance companies.
Nobody who is familiar with the market is surprised that single-payer systems are so much cheaper.
Health Care costs by country: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_heal...
Scholarly Analysis: http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single-payer-resources
> they lack perverse incentives to allow costs to rise
But, of course, they also lack incentive to actually provide all that much care, so long as those who are inconvenienced are politically unimportant (e.g. disabled newborns), and they have plenty of incentive to provide more care for the politically connected.
In practice, we can just look at existing single payer systems and see how they're doing. Would you rather be a poor parent of a disabled child in the US or the UK?
The ACA pretty much doubles down on employer-provided health insurance that covers many routine costs, which doesn't address that issue.
In other words: the healthcare discussion in America revolved around "how can we make it so everyone can afford this $300 asprin?" rather than, "Why are we letting hospitals charge $300 for asprin?"
A very clever smokescreen.