Everyone should agree that a college degree has some positive impact on future earnings. The problem is that the real cost of that degree has been doubling every decade for more than 30 years while the real earnings of college graduates have increased very little both on an absolute basis and relative to those without a college degree. Assuming college is worth it today if these trends continue it's net value (benefit - cost) will rapidly decline. This is a problem.
That's probably not the right way to look at the data -- too many weird factors (what is the distribution in the brackets, how are the brackets defined, etc...).
The best study that I've seen that breaks this out is a bit old (2002), but still probably relevant is from the US Census:
http://www.census.gov/prod/2002pubs/p23-210.pdf
It shows that over a lifetime there is a significant benefit in having a bachelors. Furthermore, having a bachelors sets you up to get further degrees later in your career.