Re:What’s Wrong with Git? A Conceptual Design Analysis
by anon4 on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @10:53AM
(#6991046)
But you can do broken commits just as easily with svn - I've seen people commit all changed files, forgetting to add a new file and making an unworking commit. You can as well commit any files you want and make as much of a mess as with git. Except with git you can test your commit before it's pushed to the server.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What’s Wrong with Git? A Conceptual Design Analysis
by haberman on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @12:21PM
(#6991562)
> But you can do broken commits just as easily with svn - I've seen people commit all changed files, forgetting to add a new file and making an unworking commit.
If you do that, you've made a mistake. No tool can save you from all mistakes (though they can help you out with warning messages and such).
Partially-staging a commit in Git is doing the same thing on purpose. It's functionality that explicitly helps you make this mistake.