Re:Apple fined for price fixing
by JohnTHaller on Monday December 30, 2013 @12:22PM
(#6985565)
There's not as much profit as you'd think. And a lot less than lower priced phones from other manufacturers. Plus, the carriers have to assume a ton of risk by agreeing to buy millions of iPhones whether they sell or not. Verizon had an estimated shorfall of $12-14 billion dollars as of July of iPhones they'd have to buy even though they didn't have the sales to warrant it. Not sure how that would up.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That shortfall was predicted by one analyst and it never occurred:
Re:Apple fined for price fixing
by JohnTHaller on Thursday January 02, 2014 @02:46PM
(#7001768)
Ah, thanks. Wasn't aware of that.
I was thinking more like this...
Currently, AT&T charges you $199 for an iPhone 5S, then has to cover $19 of subsidy over the 24 months of the $80/month contract.
A new carrier could charge $99 for an iPhone 5S, and make a huge splash. That would require another $4 of subsidy per month, but it would be pretty easy to just raise their plan to $85. Since they aren't just a retailer selling a single product once, it's much easier to move costs around. Similar to how a car dealer can play games with funding to make a car cost less but not really cost any profit.