News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by Touche on Monday December 30, 2013 @08:40AM (#6984535)
IANAL and have always wondered why this practice is allowed in the U.S.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by bradleyland on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:01AM (#6984842)
The article doesn't go in to great detail, but based on the information given, I would say that this specific practice is already prohibited in the U.S.. The relevant excerpt:

"Apple Asia ... required carriers to obtain its permission before setting contract prices on iPhones..."

This sounds like Apple Asia explicitly approved contract prices, but it depends on how you interpret "setting contract prices". If that literally means setting the price that the customer will pay, then this is not (to my knowledge) the exact mechanism used in the U.S., because the manufacturers cannot approve or deny the actual selling price. Instead, manufacturers rely on a loophole.

Rather than saying, "You can't sell an iPhone for less than $199 with contract," Apple says, "You can't advertise an iPhone for less than $1xx with contract." The actual number isn't $199, as we regularly see advertisements for iPhones at discounts from retail, but not much lower. We haven't seen the agreements, so we don't know the actual terms. It may be that Apple has the ability to approve/deny all advertised prices individually.

Keep in mind that a retailer is free to sell an iPhone at whatever price point they'd like. The problem is that they have no incentive to do so. Sale prices are a means to get customers in to the store. Imagine a ridiculous hypothetical situation where Walmart advertised the iPhone 5S at $99; that would draw in a lot of customers. However, their reseller terms prevent them from doing so, therefore there is far less incentive to do so. If they can't advertise the crazy sale price, then they can't draw in the number of customers required to meet their ROI requirements for an iPhone loss-leader. The inability to advertise props up the iPhone selling price.

Apple doesn't do this just with iPhones, and this is not the only mechanism Apple uses to prop up their prices. We don't know the specific margins retailers make on Apple products, but everyone I know who has worked in the retail industry tells me that the margin on Apple products is much lower than every other PC manufacturer. I can't speak for mobile devices, as I don't know anyone in that industry.

It's also worth noting that Apple isn't the only company who employs these practices. There are a number of "high-value" brands that support their pricing this way. Tempurpedic and Rolex come to mind immediately, but I'm certain there are many more.

Re:Apple fined for price fixing by Touche on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:25AM (#6984937)
This is exactly the type of response I was hoping to get, thank you.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by octo_t on Monday December 30, 2013 @08:57AM (#6984592)
companies are allowed to give terms stating how their products are sold. presumably the same laws that allow Apple to say that in-store displays must meet certain standards (i.e. no broken/smashed devices etc)
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by michaelt on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:08AM (#6984629)
But presumably there are some restrictions as to what those terms can be. If Apple said resellers can only sell iphones to white people that would probably not be legal.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by travisp on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:09AM (#6984875)
Because if Apple said that, it would be requiring its resellers to do something they are not legally permitted to do . A contract to break a law is illegal and unenforceable. Refusing to sell phones to people because they aren't white would break the law. Selling a phone for $150, $200, or $250 is not breaking a law. So while the law may not permit Apple to require specific prices in its contracts, it's for an entirely different reason than why Apple can't tell the reseller to illegally commit racial discrimination.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by genericuser on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:47AM (#6985026)
And much like that Apple telling retailers they must sell at a specific price prevents those retailers from potentially competing with each other (not that they were likely to vary the price much due to the low margins left to them). The effect of Apple fixing prices like this is not different than if the retailers were colluding.

Yes, the practice benefits the retailers and Apple, but its effect on consumers is commonly believed to be negative hence it is prohibited in some markets.

Re:Apple fined for price fixing by smackfu on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:55AM (#6984817)
Illegal for a completely different reasons though. Discrimination vs. fair trade.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by pinaceae on Monday December 30, 2013 @08:56AM (#6984586)
you mean a hardware vendor like Apple not allowing mobile carriers to set any price for its own handsets? why exactly is this bad?
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by vidarh on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:04AM (#6984617)
Because it drastically limits competition that would otherwise put a downwards pressure on the price of these devices.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by thedrbrian on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:12AM (#6984889)
Surely android phones put downward pressure on these devices?
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by cbhl on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:39AM (#6984998)
The idea is that putting a lower price floor on iOS devices differentiates them as a premium product, so that lay people aren't inclined to think that an Android Phone with a lower price is "as good as" an iPhone.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by keerthiko on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:05AM (#6984619)
I believe the understanding is that Apple is charging the carrier directly for each handset they obtain from Apple. However for market reasons, carriers normally futz with prices at their own will. Apple is preventing this, because it's in their interest to control the market price for iProducts. Not just that, but Apple is also making demands on the price window for the plans as well thus forcefully molding the kind of demographic that could be owning an iPhone.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by pinaceae on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:16AM (#6984658)
and again, why is this bad? marketing 101, price shapes the perceived value of a product. lots of examples here on HN were elasticity, etc have been discussed. locking down re-sellers should be perfectly fine.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by Touche on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:35AM (#6984735)
Of course it's in Apple's interests to control prices, the question is whether it's in the public's interests. I'm undecided.

Apple can always control prices by being the exclusive seller of their products, that would be a valid way to do it. By selling it to a third party they, I think (again, am undecided) they give up the right to say how much it can be sold for. In the same way they can't stop you from selling your iPhone to a friend for cheap.

What they can do is not to sell to retailers who they feel are damaging their brand. In effect, this is exactly what they are doing, however they are doing it through written agreements rather than through observation.

Re:Apple fined for price fixing by jasonwocky on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:58AM (#6984832)
> Of course it's in Apple's interests to control prices, the question is whether it's in the public's interests. I'm undecided.

Whether it is or not, I'm not sure that the fines are the way to go. If "the public" thinks that these practices are anticompetitive, why not simply declare that contract provisions to that effect won't be enforced in their jurisdiction?

Re:Apple fined for price fixing by hahainternet on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:31AM (#6984718)
It's bad because it's anti consumer. People in the US seem to have forgotten the fact that the whole capitalist system ostensibly exists to make things better for the consumer.

I cannot understand people who champion anticompetitive actions like Apple's ebook conspiracy with stupid logic like "They can afford an extra dollar for an ebook if it makes the market fair".

Re:Apple fined for price fixing by dragonwriter on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:44AM (#6985020)
> People in the US seem to have forgotten the fact that the whole capitalist system ostensibly exists to make things better for the consumer.

No, it exists to make things better for the capitalist, which is why the socialists who named the system called it "capitalism" -- the entire system revolves around the interests of capital.

Its true that part of the sales pitch that capitalists use to the masses (who significantly outnumber them, and without whose complacency capitalism could not stand) is that it has the effect of making things better for the consumer, but that's not the purpose of capitalism at all.

Re:Apple fined for price fixing by spiralpolitik on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:17AM (#6984907)
Really ? I though that capitalism was an economic system in which trade, industry and the means of production are controlled by private owners with the goal of making profits in a market economy.

Clearly I need to phone up the Oxford dictionary as they say nothing about the consumer or market fairness so they must have gotten it wrong all these years...

Re:Apple fined for price fixing by icebraining on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:21AM (#6984925)
That's highly subjective. I'd claim that by being allowed to lower prices, the carriers will probably sell more iPads, putting more people in the hands of an abusive company like Apple.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by dragonwriter on Monday December 30, 2013 @10:41AM (#6985008)
That's probably the short-term effect, however, a potential longer-term effect is hurting the iPad brand image as an elite product and status symbol, depressing demand for the particular brand.

Another potential effect is less outlets selling the iPad, because if there is the potential for others to undercut the price on the same product, it becomes less valuable item in the lineup.

Another potential effect is less sales through Apple's own retail channels if some other outlets are selling below Apple's price but Apple tries to maintain it, which could mean more sales but still less money going to Apple.

Re:Apple fined for price fixing by icebraining on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:33AM (#6985237)
So existing customers will have their possessions depreciated and new costumers will have less places where to buy iPads.
Re:Apple fined for price fixing by stefan_kendall on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:12AM (#6985139)
Capitalism does not exist "for the benefit of the consumer" no more so than apples exist for the benefit of human consumption.

Free markets need not have capitalism, and vice versa, but capitalism will likely arise in any free market.

If Bob produces X, and he wants to sell X for Y dollars, how is it immoral or bad to allow others to sell X for Y dollars, but no less?

This is like saying it's "price fixing" when an app developer charges the same for his product on the play store and the App Store.

Apple did not collude with HTC; they set the price for their product.