It's something that has been debated. Do you think telecoms and utilities sprang into existence fully-formed world-wide the day you were born? These issues are not new, they date back centuries.
Re:We’re About to Lose Net Neutrality
by argumentum on Sunday December 29, 2013 @06:58PM
(#6982202)
Then how can you consider these companies to be truly private?
I don't. Neither, I'd wager, does djur, who you initially replied to. You should read his other posts in this thread.
He and I are both speaking of the practical problems of the mentality that governments shouldn't be involved at all, not arguing that telecom monopolies are a good thing.
You can't have a practical system of utilities of any sort without government involvement. That doesn't mean you have to have government-granted monopolies to nominally private companies. There are other options, like having the core utilities (e.g. fiber) be a public utility to begin with.
Until then, arguments that net neutrality violates the freedom of the ISPs don't hold up, as any state-enforced monopolies must be considered at least partially public property.