News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:06PM (#6981392)
I'm not seeing much warmongering as a cultural phenomena.

In the U.S., perhaps not. But nationalism and remilitarisation are flaring up in China and Japan, respectively.

Who exactly is supposed to invade China next decade if they don't invade today?

China, with good reason, perceives itself as being surrounded by U.S.-allied countries looking to suppress its growth. Since growth is the currency the Communist Party trades for its seat of power, this is a potentially existential issue to the elite.

The root cause of the war being the ottoman empire decaying and almost dead and everyone wanted a lucrative piece of it.

The American Pacific alliance would be a loose analogue today. China may think it can establish a suzerainty over, say, the Phillipines, betting the U.S. will balk at another costly intervention.

The Economist's point isn't that we're going to have a war in a mold of WWI - all the seats need not be filled. It's simply warning that while we're watching the S&P 500 soar to record heights on the back of booming productivity and resurgent globalisation we shouldn't ignore the fireworks that are playing out over a handful of unmanned islands in the East China Sea.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Theodores on Sunday December 29, 2013 @08:32PM (#6982540)
Clearly you have not read Siegfried Sassoon's Public Statement Of Defiance. It was published in The London Times on 17 July 1917:

"I am making this statement as an act of wilful defiance of military authority, because I believe the war is being deliberately prolonged by those who have the power to end it.

I am a soldier, convinced that I am acting on behalf of soldiers. I believe that this war, upon which I entered as a war of defence and liberation has now become a war of aggression and conquest. I believe that the purposes for which I and my fellow soldiers entered upon this war should have been so clearly stated as to have made it impossible to change them, and that, had this been done, the objects witch actuated us would now be attainable by negotiation.

I have seen and endured the suffering of the troops, and I can no longer be a party to prolong these sufferings for ends which I believe to be evil and unjust. I am not protesting against the conduct of the war, but against the political errors and insincerity's for which the fighting men are being sacrificed.

On behalf of those who are suffering now I make this protest against the deception which is being practised on them; also I believe that I may help to destroy the callous complacence with which the majority of those at home regard the continuance of agonies which they do not share, and which they have not sufficient imagination to realise."

We have not moved on from 1917. The US seeks out war for fun and profit. Peace is a disaster for the military industrial complex, war, or at least the preparation for war, has to be perpetuated. Militarism is the cancer at the heart of almost every government, most notably the USA. Even Carter wasn't able to inoculate it. Although most Americans don't want war - it is not cultural - those people in Washington want nothing more for the exact same reasons Sassoon described.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Tloewald on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:15PM (#6981418)
Go look at US action movies, video games, etc. There's plenty of warmongering going on. Heck, just within the last year we had a mass media frenzy over the prospect of bombing Syria.

Bear in mind that the US has been fighting wars against far weaker opponents for over sixty years now, and on the whole doing quite poorly. If any country ought to not be warmongering...

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by VLM on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:31PM (#6981484)
That's wimpy warmongering as in "police action" and far away. Psuedo-colonialism.

Real USA warmongering would sound like, "We're gonna invade Canada and take all the maple syrup as our manifest destiny or we'll die trying".

Even the attitude of the Italian-Ethiopian war would be more hard core than the USA now.

Depressingly, our war mongering looks more like serving an arrest warrant in Detroit than being in a world war. Militarization of cops is the depressing part.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Tloewald on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:43PM (#6981540)
Colonialism was mostly war as business as usual too. WWI was the exception.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by jessaustin on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:38PM (#6981514)
Here's the (vain) hope that their continued failures won't be used to justify even more spending.

To be fair, however, it often seems that USA military failures are more often due to terrible strategy than poor tactical capacity. I.e., many tactical units can achieve operational objectives that would be impressive in any military. It is the bloated, inept layer of general staff that weighs down the whole structure. But that's really just a reflection of the culture: look at any USA corporation.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by berntb on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:28PM (#6981465)
>> Bear in mind that the US has been fighting wars against far weaker opponents for over sixty years now

That is only natural.

The democratic peace theory (see Wikipedia) seems to work, not even USA have wars with democracies but with really unpleasant dictatorships.

With the dictators that have nuclear weapons, you had (have) MAD as in "Mutually Assured Destruction". Not even USA starts a war. Which is why every torturing, murdering and stealing junta wants nukes...

The dictators without nukes come in two flavors. With oil -- or really poor, which implies weak military. (The juntas with oil tend to be corrupt, so no good military either. Iran might be partly an exception.)

The open question here is what happens with China and democracy when the GNP/capita goes up a bit more.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Tloewald on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:37PM (#6981506)
Only if you define dictatorship as someone the US doesn't like and democracy as someone the US likes.

There's no evidence that the government of north vietnam was worse than the organized crime cartel the US backed in the south (that had monks immolating themselves in the streets in protest against them). The US also backed Saddam Hussein against Iran, overthrew a left-wing but democratically elected government in Chile and replaced it with a brutal dictatorship. Castro, for that matter, was no worse than they guys he overthrew. The US repeatedly helped quash popular uprisings in aouth america to help out corporate interests. The US was vetoing sanctions against South Africa as late as 1988.

Oh, and check out our awesome middle eastern ally Saudi Arabia.

Learn some freaking history.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Tloewald on Sunday December 29, 2013 @05:01PM (#6981628)
@bertb

Communism isn't worse than anything no matter how bad. It's hard to determine how bad some of the less nasty communist regimes such as Cuba and Vietnam would have been without massive economic sanctions from the US. (Both Cuba and Vietnam wanted to be US allies.)

There are several cases among my examples of the US taking action against real democracies.

Some references:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fulgencio_Batista

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Politics_of_Heroin_in_South...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1973_Chilean_coup_d'état

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d'état

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by berntb on Sunday December 29, 2013 @05:43PM (#6981825)
The subject was war. You started talking about your USA hatred.

I asked for examples after the cold war (stupid of me to feed the trolls).

You don't have anything relevant here either, so you list cases that are 40+ years old...

This is a common pattern -- you can excuse anything (including burning food on the stove) with that a bad dictator had common interests with USA 50+ years ago...

It is seriously funny when left wingers blame that all communist countries are dictators on USA.

As I noted already, the non-communist dictators in that part of the world are gone since a long time. So Batiste would almost certainly be gone too. If Cuba implemented human rights, left governments in West Europe would take care of them.

>>Communism isn't worse than anything no matter how bad.

Oh my, I hope you are trolling.

I've seen this before. If I e.g. mention millions of dead repeatedly, you will do a "no true scotsman" variant. Or some more strange logic. I know the QED anyway, all the dead are USAs fault...

Enough.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Tloewald on Sunday December 29, 2013 @10:04PM (#6982793)
I see you've inferred I am a "left winger" full of "USA hatred" and a "troll". You've also skillfully defeated arguments I have not made (e.g. blaming millions of deaths or lack of democracy in communist countries on the US).

And having done this you've declared "enough".

Well played.

Incidentally, I love the US and happen to live here. I simply wish the US would stop making really foolish decisions that waste blood and treasure on idiotic adventures which harm its standing in the world. I certainly don't think that any other power, either historical (e.g. the USSR) or speculative (e.g. China or India) is likely to do a better job, or be any "nicer" than the US has been thus far. But we can always do better, and the way to do better is to recognize past mistakes.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by berntb on Monday December 30, 2013 @01:36AM (#6983386)
You troll, then insinuate I troll. Classic trick to blame others for what you do yourself -- someone browsing will just see two people calling each others names.

You wrote this weird garbage:

>>Communism isn't worse than anything no matter how bad.

That is typical left wing dishonesty, motivated with some Western country (usually USA) being dependent on and cooperating with an unpleasant dictator that is opressive and/or did mass murders.

If you have some other way of explaining that (drugs?), please do.

>>You've also skillfully defeated arguments I have not made (e.g. blaming millions of deaths or lack of democracy in communist countries on the US).

See previous paragraphs. You also wrote this:

>> It's hard to determine how bad some of the less nasty communist regimes such as Cuba and Vietnam would have been without massive economic sanctions from the US.

I can only read that as: "These enslaving juntas would have implemented human rights if it weren't for USA". Stupid.

Also see the debate history:

You changed the subject from war to realpoilitik complaints (which all countries do and lie about). It was stupid of me to comment on that and asking for examples post Cold War (which you didn't acknowledge you lack). Then you got weird (see above).

But ok, you might just lack a clue and not be a troll.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by vidarh on Monday December 30, 2013 @08:07AM (#6984427)
With respect to his statement of communism, I believe you misread what he wrote, and so you are down-voted because others interpretation does not match yours.

Read it as "communism is not automatically worse that any other possibility you can think of". E.g. compare Cuba under Castro with Germany under Hitler. The latter was obviously worse, simply because Castro did not initiate any genocides. That does not mean Castro is good, just that his stated ideology does not automatically place his regime in the "worst" category - there have been too many really nasty regimes for that.

This is assuming and accepting a right wing interpretation of "communism" to begin with.

> I can only read that as: "These enslaving juntas would have implemented human rights if it weren't for USA". Stupid.

Then your imagination is rather poor.

There are many reasons to think that overall suffering in these countries would have been less, even if the political restrictions might have remained the same. But even that is too simplistic. Castro went to the US first, including a "PR tour" where he was unable to get a visit with anyone senior in the White House. He was rebuffed over the issue of nationalisation that affected US interests, and first then did he walk into the open arms of the Soviets. It took a further several years before his party added "Socialist" to his name, and officially started adopting Soviet terminology.

Similarly, Ho-Chi-Mihn was a nationalist first, who looked to the US as a model for Vietnamese independence, and who appealed to Woodrow Wilson for support for Vietnamese independence.

It was first when this failed that Ho was radicalised further, but even then he largely held on to a nationalist outlook for a long time, while turning to socialist groups for support. Despite his radicalisation, which eventually lead to becoming one of the founder of the French communist party, and an official of the Comintern, during World War II he was supported by the US OSS in fighting the Vichy French and Japanese occupation forces.

But after the war, US support again disappeared when France attempted to re-occupy the country, and he saw no other alternative but to expand warfare and eventually fight those he originally hoped would be the guarantors of a free, independent Vietnam,.

This is a common thread with many of the revolutionary groups over the last century, who have first turned to the US or other democratic countries for support, found that they as groups are "inconvenient" because the dictatorships they oppose or opposed were often considered safer partners, and who have then instead turned elsewhere.

You even see it with the ANC in South Africa, which had an extremely tight relationship with the SACP (South African Communist Party) that deepened as Cuba provided assistance as well as intervened militarily in the South African puppet states of Angola and Namibia. ANC received support from that camp for decades while the West still provided extensive support and/or trade to the Apartheid regime. It would not have taken much for SA to have ended up taking a similar turn to Cuba or Vietnam.

A vast number of these regimes would either have looked very different, or even been open to extensive concessions to the West if "our" governments had been at all concerned with supporting democracy movements rather than propping up convenient trading partners or regimes they saw as strategic partners against the Soviets or Chinese.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by berntb on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:49PM (#6981571)
Sigh... The subject was war not realpolitik games of common interests, which all countries play (and lie about).

Most of those games also went away with the cold war.

An irrelevant question about your claims:

I don't know about Cuba's number of political prisoners, executions at revolution time, control of information, police state mentality. It might be less bad than the previous junta, but it is worst in the Americas now since the other unpleasant juntas disappeared... Afaik, the south Vietnam regime was horribly corrupt but can it really be worse than a communist place?! (Is that ideology? Do you have references?)

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by userulluipeste on Monday December 30, 2013 @09:30AM (#6984710)
"«I'm not seeing much warmongering as a cultural phenomena.» In the U.S., perhaps not."

I am not sure if there was ever a time when warmongering was looked upon more casually than today, and that is valid especially in U.S. considering the tolerant attitude toward violence in movies, video games, etc. So I would say it is exactly that, a cultural phenomena. (You'd need to look at it from outside your cultural frame if it is not obvious as it is). I'm not saying that it entirely specific to a culture though. There is a shift in how things are handled in an armed conflict that contributes to the perception of war. Before, war meant one's personal physical exposure (as a fighting soldier) whereas now that is becoming increasingly less so. Human soldiers today are needed not so much for tactical combat, but as an interacting human agent in the war zone (e.g. acting police for occupied civilian population).