News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by npt4279 on Sunday December 29, 2013 @03:51PM (#6981321)
Thankfully, I don't see WWIII starting anytime soon...

But I've always strongly thought the "globalisation will make war unthinkable" argument is naive. We're tribal creatures -Nationalism trumps economic interest at the end of the day. History shows this to be true.

As the author hinted at - Russia, Germany, Britain, Belgium, and France were each other's biggest trading partners - by far! Heck, a Belgium company built both the Belgium fortifications... and the German artillery that eventually breached them!

Nowadays, the entire world is trading... but Europe in 1914 was a good example of this principle applying continent-wide.

Convince society the other side is evil and a threat; dismiss and degenerate the peace-mongers as unpatriotic... and economic interest be damned.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by nawitus on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:55PM (#6981592)
>Nationalism trumps economic interest at the end of the day. History shows this to be true.

I interpret history as "nationalism used to trump economic interests". A lot of has changed since. Most countries are representative democracies, and it's more difficult for leaders to go into a war.

As for the tribal argument, I think the "nation state" is dying. Tribes are subcultures these days[1]. The internet connects me to my subcultures (like Hacker News), and it matters less every year what country I happen to physically live in. There's also the argument that the world is more united these days (particularly thanks to the European Union and somewhat because of United Nations).

1. http://www.gwern.net/The%20Melancholy%20of%20Subculture%20So...

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by npt4279 on Sunday December 29, 2013 @05:39PM (#6981807)
>Most countries are representative democracies, and it's more difficult for leaders to go into a war.

I agree representative democracies are far less likely to go to war. I also don't think war is likely anytime in the present era. On the other hand, China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea are not representative democracies. They represent a fair portion of earth's landmass, population, and potential destructive power. I'd say the trend towards democracy has already peaked, and authoritarian governments are on the rise.

>As for the tribal argument, I think the "nation state" is dying.

I think we have very different worldviews on this subject, so a debate isn't going to be productive. But from where I'm coming from, it's easy to be idealistic when we're living in a golden age of peace and prosperity (despite the great recession). I'm more pessimistic about humanity in times of scarcity, disasters, and conflict.

> There's also the argument that the world is more united these days (particularly thanks to the European Union and somewhat because of United Nations).

I truly hope post-WWII institutions like these continue to have force for as long as possible. I think the world is safe from major war as long as this continues. But eventually, be it 50 years or 500 hundred years, they will fall.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by olefoo on Sunday December 29, 2013 @06:06PM (#6981928)
You could make a fairly strong argument that these days the US is not much of a representative democracy; and that it is more of an elite oligarchy which performs a theater of democracy for public consumption. When overt criminal activity by elite institutions goes unpunished (see NSA, HSBC, Goldman Sachs, etc.) and popular movements for reform are crushed (Occupy) or coopted (Tea Party); it's hard to claim the moral high ground for our form of governance.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by dragonwriter on Monday December 30, 2013 @01:36PM (#6986025)
> You could make a fairly strong argument that these days the US is not much of a representative democracy; and that it is more of an elite oligarchy which performs a theater of democracy for public consumption.

To the extent that you could make such an argument "these days", you could make an even stronger argument for the same thing at almost any time in the past history of the U.S.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by olefoo on Monday December 30, 2013 @11:43PM (#6989006)
Well, you could, but there are ebbs and flows. And right now the party of money seems to be riding roughshod over the party of the people.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by userulluipeste on Monday December 30, 2013 @01:17PM (#6985922)
"Most countries are representative democracies, and it's more difficult for leaders to go into a war."

That maybe was true before, when the "democracy" craftsmanship wasn't mastered well enough. Now, I'll never bet against a government's ability to sway, at least for a while, the public perception in whatever direction, no matter how misplaced it might be. And to start a war, "for a while" is all it takes! ...Saddam's WMD?

"I think the "nation state" is dying."

Reality check - ask the Palestinians why do they want so bad a "palestinian" state when there already is an Israeli one in place? Or for that matter ask a Jew the the same question - is it that important to have an Israeli state?

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by dragonwriter on Monday December 30, 2013 @01:34PM (#6986014)
> Most countries are representative democracies, and it's more difficult for leaders to go into a war.

There's not really a lot of evidence that representative democracies are any less likely to go to war than otherwise similarly-situated nations with different government forms.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by panabee on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:51PM (#6981578)
Interesting perspective. Agree that national interests ultimately trump economic interests. At the same time, what would advance the discussion even more is data on how critical international trade was/is to each country. For instance, what % of GDP for pre-WWI Germany came from beyond its borders vs. present-day China. Globalization may not prevent war, but perhaps it's possible that more intertwined relationships -- whether through deeper financial gain or cultural understanding -- could decrease the likelihood of world war.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by userulluipeste on Monday December 30, 2013 @01:42PM (#6986070)
"More intertwined relationships" may also become inconvenient shackles, especially when are used as political leverage (look at Russia with its exports of natural gas in Europe, or at the economic sanctions against Iran). Heck, look at history - given the right condition, an economical relationship by itself can start a war if it cease, becomes abusive, or is altered in some inconvenient way! And as power balance is in continuous change, so are the economical relations shadowed by it.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by npt4279 on Sunday December 29, 2013 @05:50PM (#6981854)
I'd love to have this data! Anyone have it handy? Google doesn't seem to be helping me.

I also agree that deeper cultural understanding can only help, not hurt. I particularly wish all 7 billion of us had the opportunity to spend a year traveling the globe and live with different peoples.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by tanzam75 on Sunday December 29, 2013 @08:33PM (#6982542)
> Heck, a Belgium company built both the Belgium fortifications... and the German artillery that eventually breached them!

Which fortifications are you talking about?

The Germans used Krupp and Skoda siege guns to reduce the fortifications at Liège. Krupp was a German company, and Skoda was an Austro-Hungarian company based in Bohemia (today's Czech Republic).

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by encoderer on Sunday December 29, 2013 @08:54PM (#6982603)
And IIRC their development was DARPA-esque? Didn't the Germans put out a standing order to arms makers for a better siege gun?

Most of what I know of WWI I learned from Guns of August :)

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by VLM on Sunday December 29, 2013 @03:58PM (#6981357)
Another interesting point about globalization is the meaning of WWI style globalization was colonialism, every European power had overseas colonies (other than Germany). Another example where world trade didn't seem to help much.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Tloewald on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:23PM (#6981450)
Um, Germany had overseas colonies, including one where they committed genocide (foreshadowing later bad acts). And do you think today's globalization isn't colonialism? Explain the real differences, including a discussion of multinationals investing in third world nations and gaining defacto control of their governments and Chinese treaties sewing up the national resources of African countries and acquiring long term leases for agricultural land all around the world.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_colonial_empire

http://www.rferl.org/content/ukraine-china-leases-farmland/2...

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by VLM on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:44PM (#6981546)
"Germany had overseas colonies"

Yeah like 3 small states in Africa almost by accident.

To compare to a "real" colonial empire take a look at the Spanish empire at peak, or the British empire around WWI, or the French colonial empire, or the Russian empire, the Dutch empire...

Needs a sense of scale. The Russian Empire around 1900 was the 3rd largest empire in history, something like 1/8th of a billion people. German colonial population from the linked wiki article before WWI, 23 thousand.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Tloewald on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:56PM (#6981598)
Yes, a point you did not make and which I did not contradict.

Indeed, the same applies to several other European "powers". Also some European nations had quite extensive overseas colonies while not really being military powers (e.g. Belgium and Holland). For that matter. Russia had no colonies that I know of.

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by VLM on Sunday December 29, 2013 @05:57PM (#6981885)
Upon re-reading our posts I think, you think, I disagree with you, more than I actually disagree or intend to appear.

There are some name game disagreements where Germany wanted to pretend to be in the colonialism game despite a totally laughable achievement level (a hundred years ago it was considered cool, not like now at all) and Russia ran the provinces of its empire much like Britain ran its colonies, other than the ocean in the middle, look at Finland for an example. Or the name game that modern world trade is not called colonialism.

So the argument that we can't have a WW3 because we have world trade, is incorrect because at WW1 time they had almost the same thing but called it colonialism and everyone but Germany was heavily into it and that didn't help prevent war very much (and yes yes OK OK Germany achieved the most pitiful level of colonialism of all the European powers, not none at all, but it rounded to zero compared to every other European power)

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by Tloewald on Sunday December 29, 2013 @06:51PM (#6982173)
Yes, I completely agree with you on the world trade point, which is the most important point with respect to the question of war. That said, the interdependence of the major prospective combatants is perhaps novel.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:26PM (#6981456)
Didn't you ever see 'The African Queen'?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_East_Africa

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by randomafrican on Monday December 30, 2013 @03:32AM (#6983697)
On the other hand, while there was a lot of trade between European powers, part of the point of colonization was to have the colonies "trade" manly with the colonizer.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by eli_gottlieb on Sunday December 29, 2013 @05:41PM (#6981814)
> We're tribal creatures -Nationalism trumps economic interest at the end of the day. History shows this to be true.

Drop the Naturalistic Fallacy, please, and the.... damn.

Is there some actual name for the particular fallacy of predictive sociology being invoked when someone says, "People will do X because it's human nature to do X!"?

Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by 1457389 on Sunday December 29, 2013 @08:46PM (#6982579)
What would you say to the argument that economic interests and power blocs wield much more influence over nations today? The political, cultural and economic establishments of most nations are now heavily infiltrated/controlled by a relatively miniscule number of financial institutions. The void left by the declining aristocracy is now arguably filled by central bankers and hedge fund managers.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by atoningunifex on Sunday December 29, 2013 @11:56PM (#6983102)
If we posit that as factually correct (and I do), what would you say is a solution or plan moving forward to change things?
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by 1457389 on Monday December 30, 2013 @12:27AM (#6983188)
I don't have a real answer yet, searching desperately though. Have to admit that I prefer what is going on now to the aristocratic and theocratic systems we had before in much of the world. The worst tyrants are the ideologues, and it seems that now the crooks have taken over instead. Anyway, nothing is going to change unless popular anger becomes a force to be reckoned with. The NSA is or will be a major obstacle to civilians organizing on a large scale and for that reason alone it must be opposed. People talk about getting better voter participation but really I think we need people in the streets, not the booths.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by atoningunifex on Monday December 30, 2013 @12:48AM (#6983238)
People in the streets... would be met with brutality and force I would think. The Occupy Wall Street folks didn't fare so well. That is my issue; there's a large body of people getting fed information, that preclude what you suggest.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by atoningunifex on Monday December 30, 2013 @12:41AM (#6983222)
I can't see an answer either, that doesn't include some form of 'global awareness' (Julian May's Unity perhaps). That is what is depressing to me; the hegemony is complete, and the means left at our disposal to stop it, are gone.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by 1457389 on Monday December 30, 2013 @02:12AM (#6983492)
Yeah, looks like the only real way involves being co-opted in turn. Seems like that's what ended up happening to Obama.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by atoningunifex on Monday December 30, 2013 @03:17AM (#6983662)
It does, but its a shit outcome. I was hoping you'd come out with a spring of hope for me :) I honestly see no good way out of this mess. Call me pessimistic, defeatist or whatever, but this is a system well sewn up. Getting out of it is impossible, I think, beyond an uprising.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by 1457389 on Monday December 30, 2013 @04:03PM (#6986929)
The greatest I hope I have is that the old media establishment becomes replaced in its entirety with a more chaotic, uncontrolled space like the internet. When people finally have access to the truth about what is going on and how it affects them, and grow up with that understanding, we will have a generation that can effect real change on a large scale. Right now unfortunately the cypherpunks and activists simply don't have the backing of the populace.
Re:Uncomfortable parallels with the era that led to the firs... by atoningunifex on Sunday December 29, 2013 @11:22PM (#6983026)
I'd say you're spot on. Much as I hate it, the Rothschild family et al have sewn it up fairly well.