News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Girls Who Code by WalterBright on Sunday December 29, 2013 @02:58PM (#6981016)
All decision making processes with a human in the loop are going to be random, arbitrary, capricious, etc. But inhumane? about a job? It actually seems very humane. After all, only a human can look past the rules and see that a candidate is someone special that would be great for the company despite not matching the criteria.

Would you rather be selected for a job by a computer that follows inflexible rules embedded in software? That would be inhumane.

Re:Girls Who Code by tptacek on Sunday December 29, 2013 @03:09PM (#6981080)
I am telling you that after watching the Nth person go through an on-site interview process that we had already actively tried to program as positive and encouraging, and seeing them physically shaking in the conference room, and then thinking back on the last time I had needed to endure a job interview and how I felt, that yes, the process is inhumane. It demands of candidates that they endure a deeply uncomfortable process of being judged in 45 minute snapshots by strangers who often by all appearances seem to have rejection as an overt goal.

Your last question presents a false dichotomy and so I won't answer it.

I am, incidentally, a fan of your comments on HN. I'm just not interested in an argument where we're both going to be talking past each other.

Re:Girls Who Code by ericd on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:42PM (#6981534)
Yeah, I completely agree - I absolutely hate interviews, to the point where I would prefer to do a large amount of work on alternative methods over a full day of interviews.