Re:Why Clipperz is moving out of the US
by dragonwriter on Sunday December 29, 2013 @01:40AM
(#6978679)
You're confusing doing "parallel construction" (which is getting information illegally and secretly and then constructing an alternative method to "discover" the same information that will seem legal when the original source of the information is concealed) [1] with invoking the "inevitable discovery" exception to the exclusionary rule [2].
While prosecutors frequently try to argue parallel construction (they would have discovered the evidence anyways through other means), judges rarely accept this argument unless the prosecution can show that such other means were already underway and yielding evidence that would have led to the tainted evidence. (This is rare, because at this point in the proceedings, the investigating agency has usually moved on to investigating other cases. The law doesn't move as fast as it does on Law & Order or CSI.)
Also...Lavabit isn't relevant. That idiot thought he came up with some brilliant "hack" of the legal system based on a bizarre misunderstanding of the law and it bit him in the ass. Even a first year law student could have told him that scheme wouldn't have worked. If he had wanted to make a subpoena-proof system which would have prevented him from actually providing decrypted customer data, he should have designed such a system. Instead, he built a system that let him decrypt customer data...while also decrypting the data for every other customer.