News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics by tptacek on Saturday December 28, 2013 @05:44PM (#6977002)
Because (1) people do not agree that SPY ETFs are a reliable way to earn a return, (2) the process of moving money in and out of ETFs is far from frictionless, and (3) once people move money into an investment vehicle, they are in fact hesitant to liquidate it simply to make purchases, in a way they are not with "currency".
Re:Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics by yummyfajitas on Sunday December 29, 2013 @04:08AM (#6978951)
Look, the real problem with deflation is that it increases real interest rates and makes structural rigidities caused by sticky wages/prices more potent. If you want to argue against bitcoin on Keynesian grounds, start there.

The only way deflation will reduce consumption is if the rate of deflation exceeds all other rates of return. Simple math: I consume if

(value of consumption now) > exp(-(discount rate - rate of return) x time) x (value of consumption in future)

The `rate of return` term is the rate of return on my best investment - this is affected by deflation primarily if the deflationary currency becomes or improves my best investment.

If you plug in some example the numbers, you'll see that the effect this has on consumption is miniscule compared to the effect this has on the allocation of investment. That's because when choosing between investments both sides of the equation have the discount rate, and it cancels.

Atmosx is appealing to newspaper column keynesianism (that vague "I dunno what AD is, but I want more of it" flavor), and doesn't really understand what he is talking about. Do a back of the envelope calculation and you'll see I'm right.