News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sherlock Holmes Is in the Public Domain, American Judge R... by dragonwriter on Friday December 27, 2013 @05:25PM (#6972879)
No, the whole point was the distinction between "discovering" and "inventing", a distinction which would not exist if "discovering" was replaced with "creating".
Re:Sherlock Holmes Is in the Public Domain, American Judge R... by crygin on Friday December 27, 2013 @06:07PM (#6973037)
You're not a Platonist, are you?

Regardless, it would be plausible to imagine a character conceived of by an author, who has curious behaviors in early stories, the motivation for which is only revealed in a much later story. This would be an example of a process of "discovery" about a character, but this discovery is happening in the form of revelations in the text rather than by the act of the author.

If you wanted to make the analogy more precise, you could imagine a character created with peculiar traits, and the author later realizes a single explanation for those traits which they had not originally conceived, which they then write into a story. In these two cases, the effect on the reader might be identical, but in one essential information about the character was held back and in one it was developed later.

All of this is a little academic, though, since none of the information about Holmes & Watson in the post-1923 stories has a material effect on their characters, as ACD's estate attempted to argue.

Re:Sherlock Holmes Is in the Public Domain, American Judge R... by mburns on Friday December 27, 2013 @07:05PM (#6973233)
> In these two cases, the effect on the reader might be identical, but in one essential information about the character was held back and in one it was developed later.

But we aren't talking about the reader. We're talking about the author. Plot reveals later in the story (that the reader experiences) have nothing to do with an author writing those things over time.

If Doyle 'discovered' Watson (not created), then Watson is not copyrightable. If Doyle created Watson (which he clearly did, being the author of a fictitious character in a series of fictional novels and stories) then Doyle didn't "discover" anything, he just refined his creation.