Re:N.S.A. Phone Surveillance Is Lawful, Federal Judge Rules
by irishmoss on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:39PM
(#6972222)
I can't imagine how the Justice Sotomayor could have been any more clear in this issue:
I would not assume that all information voluntarily disclosed
to some member of the public for a limited purpose is,
for that reason alone, disentitled to Fourth Amendment protection.
[citations omitted]
Resolution of these difficult questions in this case is unnecessary,
however, because the Government's physical intrusion on Jones' Jeep
supplies a narrower basis for decision.
When Ginsburg, Breyer, and Kagan feel surveillance is so obviously unconstitutional as to provide an even narrower basis than actual trespassing, and Sotomayor writes a separate opinion for the sole purpose of conveying she'd be the 4th vote, I find it hard to imagine how any judge could uphold this surveillance in good faith.
When Ginsburg, Breyer, and Kagan feel surveillance is so obviously unconstitutional as to provide an even narrower basis than actual trespassing, and Sotomayor writes a separate opinion for the sole purpose of conveying she'd be the 4th vote, I find it hard to imagine how any judge could uphold this surveillance in good faith.