News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by dragontamer on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:23PM (#6971540)
The point of lecture is not to "teach", the same way a high school lecture was. A College Lecture was designed to introduce concepts and clarify questions that occurred in studies.

But "learning" and "teaching" don't really happen in the lecture halls. They happen in the labs, in the after-hour question / answer sessions. After all, it is difficult for a professor to individually answer questions when there are 300 students in a hall (and similarly, most students are too shy to ask a question in front of so many people).

Surprise, college is not the baby-hand-holding that high school / grade school was. Students are expected to learn by themselves, and set up their own study groups. Students are expected to come to after-lecture study halls for clarification.

-------------------

Lets put it this way. The student is the one who is paying for the education. If the student wastes his $30,000+ by partying and socializing all day long, the problem is NOT with the professors.

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by wonderzombie on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:16PM (#6972115)
They covered this; it's sort of a rational choice, in the sense that since college is required for everyone, kids just want their certification. You or I might not like this attitude (I don't) but it's not altogether surprising, is it? Perhaps with the ascendance of such as standardized testing, you just want to get the "right" answers with the least effort.

I was like this in high school (solid B student b/c lazy), but for whatever reason, I grew out of it in college and have since reacquainted myself with the joy of learning. I can understand why the whole thing might seem like a joke, especially if everyone around you feels the same way.

Maybe we should ask questions about why kids' expectations are what they are. I'll bet you they're a lagging indicator of some characteristic(s) of our educational system. As I said upthread, as adults we're beholden to them for making sure they turn out OK. To put it charitably, it's misguided to blame kids for the results of adult decisions.

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by orclev on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:20PM (#6973748)
I've always enjoyed learning, but I despised school and most college courses. Thankfully I'm an autodidact and don't need the school system to learn or else I'm afraid I wouldn't know much of anything. The public school system is in shambles and can barely be counted on to teach the most fundamental of curriculum let alone more advanced courses that should function as the foundation of future college learning. The university system in contrast is less interested in teaching any particular thing than it is in wringing every last cent of tuition out of each student before they either drop out, flunk out, or somehow manage to navigate the various flaming hoops and traps the university's have erected to stand between students and their eventual departure from them.

Nominally the various classes are supposed to provide an opportunity to learn, but in practice they're little more than a set of speed-bumps designed to prolong the amount of time a given student spends at the university. To that end it's really in the best interest of the university to do as little actual teaching they can as opposed to as much testing as possible, and it's largely reflected in the curriculum of many professors.

Once you've cleared the bar of the bachelors however things change somewhat. With most students leaving after attaining a bachelors (or a masters in the case of business students, and a PhD in the case of medical students), those left are destined to become faculty (or at least attempt to become faculty) and to take part in the other major fundraising activity in the university system, the attaining of grants. At this point the emphasis shifts from delaying attainment of your degree to press-ganging you into becoming a cog in the grant generating departments. In the post-grad track you're only as good to the university as the grant dollars you're helping to bring in.

Ultimately the problem boils down to the shift in emphasis of universities from places of higher learning, to businesses geared around extracting maximum profit from each individual customer in exchange for a largely meaningless paper that HR departments around the country still have a fetishistic devotion to.

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by j2kun on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:48PM (#6971660)
But the onus is on the institution to only grant degrees to those who deserve it. The worthlessness comes when you start giving bachelor's degrees to people who chose to waste their tuition on partying, and this is what's happening.
Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by HarryHirsch on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:59PM (#6971727)
But the onus is on the institution to only grant degrees to those who deserve it

Unfortunately, with an ever greater share of universities' budgets coming from tuition, they cannot afford to throw people out. It's also why you see so many summer courses offered where for lack of time they cannot even hope to cover the material appropiately, and it's why you see this proliferation of taught masters degrees. It's disgusting, and it ought to stop.

worthlessness comes when you start giving bachelor's degrees to people who chose to waste their tuition on partying

Taught Masters degrees sold to students whose GPA isn't sufficient to get them into medical school are a different kind of worthless. They are disgusting and reprehensible.

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by Scienz on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:49PM (#6971995)
they cannot afford to throw people out.

Not always true. I flunked out of my last school due largely to depression issues and extreme isolation which led to heavy drinking and low grades. My advisor, who I'd only talked to once before when switching into that major, was so happy to see me go he wouldn't even speak to me when I needed him to sign a form so I could drop out, instead of failing out. Instead just told me he was busy and left me sitting outside his office for an hour and a half before I finally got the point (I waited so long because I at first assumed he was actually busy, and not just blowing me off). Needless to say it's hard to do well at a school in spite of isolation and depression when your professors automatically assume you're just a lazy shit who isn't trying and your advisor won't even let you into their office. I know in his head he was probably "upholding the quality of the degree for the alumni" or some shit, but it's hard to justify that when they're doing so based on snap judgments about students who depend on them and who they've never even really spoken to, and furthermore refuse to. Also, to justify that I'm not actually as much of a loser as this guy thought I was, I should say that part of the depression was due to failing to maintain a 4.0 GPA in my classes (I wanted to go to grad school for physics and felt this was required). I found out later I'd actually been one of only three students to even pass the hardest class, and somehow ended up with a B in it despite thinking I was failing the entire time.

Trust me, they do not give a fuck about you. Unless you can get their name on a paper you're publishing, you're just an ID number and a tuition payment to them.

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by j2kun on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:41PM (#6972227)
Not all schools are like that. My alma mater had no research program, and all the professors did was teach. Though the student body was largely comprised of partiers, so you may have gotten the same sort of treatment.

That being said, it sounds like you're a proponent of the "alternative routes" that the OP suggests at the end of the article.

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by Scienz on Friday December 27, 2013 @03:12PM (#6972392)
I am indeed a huge proponent of the alternative routes method. My criticisms of higher education could go on for a long time, and I'm not even going to try and list them all here. My experience has also been that professors who also do research are not nearly as good teachers as the ones who don't. The best teachers I had were in community college, despite probably not being as "qualified" or well-versed in the subjects as the ones publishing papers, a good number of them actually cared about the students and went out of their way to help you get through the class. Counterintuitively, it seems the more prestigious the school the more self-centered and hostile the professors.
Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by j2kun on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @01:18AM (#6989326)
This is true. In research communities they actively tell graduate students not to care about teaching because it looks bad on a CV to have teaching awards, etc.
Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by yaddayadda on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:54PM (#6972300)
I'm sorry to hear about your experience. While there are many professors with attitudes similar to the professor you described, certainly not all professors have the same attitude.

For my undergraduate degree, I was lucky to go to community colleges and a small, private college. By and large, the instructors at the community colleges defaulted to such an attitude, but if you had brief conversations with them and let them know what was going on in your life, they were willing to work with you. At the community college level, I've heard of exceptions, but they have been extremely rare (and I come from an academic family that has ties to community college level institutions across the U.S.). At the small, private college, professors actively worked with students and knew what was going in their lives. I only met one exception, and that professor was summarily "let go" after only a semester.

At the graduate level, I've seen exceptionally supportive and exceptionally hostile professors. And I've seen many professors who will be supportive of one or two students to the detriment of others (in the circles I come from it even has a name, the "mini-me"). I had one professor who exemplified the hostile, even when I had a series of well-documented life crises and tried to work with him. While my other professors worked with me, this individual would make no allowances - to include allowing me to miss class to have emergency surgery to prevent imminent quadriplegia. Needless to say, my health crisis took priority. When I returned, I notified my department chair and the graduate school dean. While the professor was allowed to continue to treat students with a rough hand, I was given allowances to get back on track and I subsequently learned that the graduate school changed policies to prevent situations like mine from happening to other students.

I've also had the opportunity to teach several classes. As long as the student keeps me updated and is making forward academic progress, I'll support the student; with the one exception of teamwork. By default, I try to limit teamwork to the bare minimum appropriate for academic purposes, and even then I have tried to work with students who are suffering from external stressors. In graduate school, anything less than a B is tantamount to failing. I've given two students grades less than a B. In both cases, I reached out to the student many times, and made it clear that the student was doing extremely poorly, and tried to find out what was going on and what could be done to get the student across the proverbial academic finish-line. In both cases, the students would simply tell me they had been having a hard time at home, but things had changed there, and they would be more engaged with coursework. In both cases, this happened frequently, and there was never any increased engagement. Denying there is a problem is denying others the opportunity to help you.

So, (a) please do not allow one professor to scare you away, (b) please do keep your professors up-to-date on anything that will impact your ability to meet academic goals, (c) if you don't get acceptable support from your professors, seek help from support services (e.g., the ADA office) and move up the chain-of-command (e.g., department chair), and (d) if you're passionate about physics, find a mentor that can help you navigate your program and move on to an appropriate graduate program!

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by Scienz on Friday December 27, 2013 @04:18PM (#6972662)
Those are good suggestions, but I'd mention that it's much easier for me now to analyze my situation in retrospect, understand what happened and the mistakes I made, and turn it into a cohesive narrative. At the time I didn't really understand why I was doing poorly or what the root causes were, so while I did seek "support" on a number of occasions, it didn't help. I simply assumed I wasn't smart enough to graduate, much less do physics. In retrospect I see this obviously wasn't true, since I'm happily reading a quantum field theory book in my spare time now and, as I said before, ended up being one of the better students in some of my classes. But if you'd asked me at the time I'd have probably just rambled a bunch of guesses and speculation. I suppose my point is that, even following those suggestions, some people will still fall through the cracks. And also that most of these institutions are just bureaucratic monoliths that aren't built to be flexible with every students particular needs and such. The bias there tends to be heavily towards the institutions, too, since students who do poorly are just deemed slackers or unfit for college, instead of considering it a systemic or structural aspect of the system that favors certain people and situations over others. Even the stereotypical "partiers" who drink their way through college could be viewed as a systemic result of a toxic social environment. I believe there was another comment here to the effect of "this is college and you're done with baby hand-holding," which is true in one sense, but it shouldn't be used as an excuse to disregard anyone doing badly in the system or a particular school as acceptable attrition for a just-good-enough educational system.
Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by yaddayadda on Saturday December 28, 2013 @02:05PM (#6975862)
> Those are good suggestions, but I'd mention that it's much easier for me now to analyze my situation in retrospect, understand what happened and the mistakes I made, and turn it into a cohesive narrative. At the time I didn't really understand why I was doing poorly or what the root causes were, so while I did seek "support" on a number of occasions, it didn't help.

Sadly, this is likely to have been true no matter where you were (e.g., college or workplace). In my experience, in an academic environment simply expressing that there is something wrong and seeking a little bit of help will frequently lead to help. I had several bouts of debilitating depression in the military (way suckier than in an academic environment ;-) ). During one of these, I found out some very powerful information about one leader in our unit (i.e., I learned about something that could have led to him being discharged dishonorably). Thankfully, he recognized my depression, so we made a deal. As a result I was able to get off-the-record therapy from a local, civilian counselor, but there were no concessions at work. While I was in school I dealt with several more bouts of depression. In most cases, simply telling the professor that I wasn't up my normal speed (i.e. never saying I was depressed; in several cases, I wasn't aware that it was happening again) led to delayed deadlines or other concessions. I happened to be in university during a particularly bad bout of depression and a classmate took me to the university clinic. My classmate had a conversation with the doctor before I saw the doctor (I can only imagine what was said). That was the first time I was formally diagnosed, and it was the first time I was prescribed anti-depressants. As I mentioned previously, I have a lot of academic family ties, and I hear about situations like this very frequently. I've never heard about similar support in a non-academic workplace.

> I simply assumed I wasn't smart enough to graduate, much less do physics. In retrospect I see this obviously wasn't true, since I'm happily reading a quantum field theory book in my spare time now and, as I said before, ended up being one of the better students in some of my classes. But if you'd asked me at the time I'd have probably just rambled a bunch of guesses and speculation. I suppose my point is that, even following those suggestions, some people will still fall through the cracks. And also that most of these institutions are just bureaucratic monoliths that aren't built to be flexible with every students particular needs and such.

Remember that institutions, even bureaucratic monolithic institutions, are made of people. In my experience, the people in academic institutions are particularly helpful if they know, or even just suspect, that a student needs help. The biggest single success factor I've seen is having a mentor (hence my last tip). This is not to say that you can succeed without a lot of hard work, but having a mentor helps you find the help that you need, when you need it (e.g., taking you to the doctor to be diagnosed with depression; getting an interlibrary loan ASAP; giving you career advice; letting you know where you rank in your program).

> The bias there tends to be heavily towards the institutions, too, since students who do poorly are just deemed slackers or unfit for college, instead of considering it a systemic or structural aspect of the system that favors certain people and situations over others. Even the stereotypical "partiers" who drink their way through college could be viewed as a systemic result of a toxic social environment. I believe there was another comment here to the effect of "this is college and you're done with baby hand-holding," which is true in one sense, but it shouldn't be used as an excuse to disregard anyone doing badly in the system or a particular school as acceptable attrition for a just-good-enough educational system.

This is extremely institution-specific. I have seen and heard about institutions, or departments, like this, but I've experienced and heard about many more that are vested in their students' success, both in and out of the classroom. If you can complete your bachelors degree at a small, private institution, I'd highly recommend it! (I've never heard of a small, private institution that wasn't extremely vested in their students' success in and out of class.) I wish I had known when I was an undergrad that there were "free" options (they aren't actually free, but are extremely low-cost). The only free college that I can vouch for (i.e. I know a successful alumnus who speaks highly of the experience) is http://www.deepsprings.edu/home and it only awards associate degrees. The friend I know who is an alumnus is now a professor in the sciences at a top university. He credits much of his academic success to his experiences at and friendships from Deep Springs.

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by al2o3cr on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:39PM (#6971938)
"Deserve" seems to be a highly-loaded word here. If you can't remember anything taught in a class a year after taking it, do you really "deserve" credit for learning it? How would such a thing even be measured, let alone enforced?
Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by j2kun on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:36PM (#6972201)
Again, this is the job of the university. A degree is a university vouching for the education of a student. So what I mean is the university should only give degrees to those students that the university deems worthy. The problem is that that bar is too low for too many universities, or the bar is in wrong place altogether.
Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by hosh on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:54PM (#6972017)
This is a fair point.

However, now that college loans are collateralized, I don't think many college students really feel the pain and stake put into getting a college education.

I took courses at a community college for a stint. The courses I took during the day were drastically different from the courses I took during the night.

The day classes were filled with young college kids, not much different from the classes I took at Ohio State, all "clocking in" to put in their time.

The night classes were filled with professionals trying to get a Business Administration degree. They all work full time. Many have families that they are giving up time with to spend in class. Many are paying for college on their own, or through their jobs. The level of maturity and interest was significantly higher.

Justifying humanities is a bit more difficult. There are no observable practical employment opportunities with the humanities. Instead, they are meant to open up self-awareness, to give words and expression to one's own narrative, and in coming to greater understanding of self, it helps one to better navigate in the world. You don't get into the humanities to be able to get a job. You get into the humanities to get a handle on your life. In some ways, this is a much more profound education than an engineering program that teaches you how to make stuff. And I wonder, what would happen for those night school folks who self-select into humanities?

Re:We Pretend to Teach, They Pretend to Learn by wonderzombie on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:18PM (#6972124)
I agree with you re: humanities. I should also say that I think it's a shame if what's "useful" is the only thing that we, as a society, decide to focus on. What about literature, art, and culture? Should we just content ourselves with Hollywood blockbusters and reality TV?