Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco
by blasdel on Thursday July 09, 2009 @09:12PM
(#696949)
The web's ideology is to not give a shit -- no baseline content types were ever specified for <img> or <object> or <embed>
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Yes, and "not giving a shit" gave us the fun we had with GIF89 (Will Compuserve shut down the web?!?), various incompatible video formats (Real, AVI, etc.), so this time around, giving a shit might save us from having to go thru all that again.
The LZW GIF patent trolling was from Unisys (It was a submarine patent for Compuserve), and it only affected encoders -- it didn't threaten the web in any way.
The video wars were because [Apple, MS, Real, Macromedia, Sun] were all trying to compete with each other using crap products that conflated [Branding, Plugin, Container Format, Codec] in a mash of uselessness.
Flash won not because it had the same codecs on all platforms, the plugin was customizable the same way on all platforms, and the end-user branding was all yours to theme.
The most interesting part of <video> is not codecs or containers, but the full + uniform control and customizability via its Javascript API. The only reason there is any problem at all is because Mozilla is refusing to expose access to QT / DirectShow / GStreamer.
Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco
by weavejester on Friday July 10, 2009 @04:50AM
(#697343)
This is true, but I wonder whether this would have been the case had more image formats been patent-encumbered. The web is a product of open standards and formats, and Firefox is attempting to apply that ideology to HTML5 video formats as well.