News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco by jerf on Thursday July 09, 2009 @07:23PM (#696837)
This is the 10,000 eyes of open source catching the mistake. It happens in public because there is very little "private". Working As Designed.

How often do you see a forensic analysis of this type on commercial software? Not zero, but less often.

Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco by tptacek on Thursday July 09, 2009 @09:32PM (#696974)
I'm gonna go with, "every time Microsoft releases a security patch of any severity in any product whatsoever".
Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco by jerf on Thursday July 09, 2009 @09:38PM (#696977)
Hey, absolutely. I'm just saying that it's much harder and thus much more rare.

(I have to admit it's sort of more impressive when someone whips out a debugger rather than reading through source.)

Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco by CWuestefeld on Thursday July 09, 2009 @09:59PM (#696990)
Well, catching it after a long beta and then three rounds of release candidates. Indeed, it was apparently caught by an end user, and not those 10K eyes of developers at all.
Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco by rbanffy on Friday July 10, 2009 @11:08AM (#697727)
And that's the beauty of FLOSS. An end-user caught a problem that will, hopefully, be corrected in a couple days.

Were it a problem within IE (or Oracle applications - let's be fair as this is not a Microsoft-only problem) we would have to wait until a developer reads the report, the bug being assigned and the correction being put in a future bug-fix release.

In a way, a guy from Microsoft just made a huge point on how open-source is far superior to their own closed development cycle.

Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco by FooBarWidget on Friday July 10, 2009 @05:39AM (#697379)
I'm not sure what you're expecting or what you're disappointed about. It's not like closed source commercial software have any better track records.
Re:The Firefox 3.5 fiasco by jeffesp on Friday July 10, 2009 @08:38AM (#697562)
If we only measure ourselves (and our work) by the next best person, then only thing we can become is slightly better than them.