How is that different from paying bloggers to write a product review with a link to a product? Why is not that considered a "manipulation of SERPs" - you exchange (money/tweet) for a link.
Those types of links reviews for a link, are considered advertorials which Interflora were "famously" penalised[3] for and something Google specifically identifies within their Link Scheme examples[2]
[1] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/35769
[2] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66356
[3] http://searchengineland.com/google-says-no-comment-on-why-in...
I was about to ask if the lesson to draw here was to make it look organic.
But mostly serious question here: how does TechCrunch have any Google rank then? How do most tech publications, for that matter? PR hits are extremely common; they're the name of the game when it comes to cheap content.
It's okay if it looks like it's mutual self interest, and not if it overtly competes with Google's advertising platform?
TechCrunch does not post advertorials, they post content for free and they actually posted on their site to reaffirm this fact[1].
Sure there may be some PR firms etc who might get paid to get that content on to TechCrunch or another tech publications but TechCrunch writers are not directly compensated for doing so.
As a result the content they write from a startup launch to a new feature etc is considered "natural" by the search engines as they're choosing to write about it.
Moreover, those publications get the majority of their search engine traffic through being in Google News ala. posting about "Twitter" and getting inserted into the "Twitter" SERPs within the "News" section. Additionally they also leverage internal linking to boost their SERPs potential e.g. whenever they talk about Zulily (they're in #9 for me in Incognito mode although they might be higher/ on Page 2 for you) instead of linking to the site they'll reference the "Tag URL"[2] as well as referencing Crunchbase[3] (although CrunchBase isn't really 'internal' as its an external site). Likewise, Google loves "fresh content" so they will naturally be inserted with little/no links within the top 7ish results for something generic (although this does not always happen) such as "credit card numbers" when they do a post about "credit card numbers" and will naturally lose search engine positioning for that term over time.
[1] http://techcrunch.com/2012/11/08/we-are-worth-at-least-3k/
However, they're acceptable if they do not carry any link equity (aka. use the no follow tag) on the link.
[1] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66356
[2] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/35769?hl=en
Typically they don't know what nofollow is, and their sites are run by people who don't really know much about websites.
I can't educate the entire sector. Is it better to steer clear of link building with this broad swath of sites? Most of the other sites in my niche have built links through these sites.
There is a shortage of followed links in my niche as most content creators in my narrow field are commercial and don't link to competitors.
However, Penguin is not the only way which Google identifies people being involved in these practices as they also have a place to report the links[3].
This is one of Google's Manual Actions[4] that webmasters receive, when Google believes you are not providing the user with additional value and/or are trying to manipulate the results.
They cover everything from Thin Content (mainly through Panda) to Hacked Sites to User Generated Spam to the recent Image Mismatch Penalty etc. You can see them all here: https://support.google.com/webmasters/topic/2604771?hl=en&re...
[1] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/35769
[2] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66356
[3] https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/paidlinks?pli=1&hl=e...
[4] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/2604824?hl=en