News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by fit2rule on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @09:35AM (#6963054)
What the heck is an "A-Player" or a "B-Player"? I think this is another American sporting term that has no place in the technology field, personally .. is it not discrimination wrapped up in a pop-cult package?
Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by drewhk on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @12:10PM (#6963428)
It's a marketing term invented by companies for recruiting. If you think about it, A-Player simply means: "the people who we decided to hire". The idea is brilliant:

- If you are rejected, it is your fault. You are not good enough.

- If you are fired, it is you fault. You are no longer good enough.

- While you are working there, it boosts your ego, because you are "one of the elite", a "no compromise high-performer", a "rockstar" an "A-Player", etc. and you feel no empathy for the fired/rejected ones -- "they were not good enough, but I am!". And of course you do everything to remain employed, since that is what makes you the cool kid.

Of course other products are marketed in a similar fashion, by artificially creating a feel of "exclusivism" -- it is just a bit harder to recognize it in the software world, since it is designed to push our own "secret nerd desire button" (feeling mentally superior to others).

Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by bjustin on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @11:15AM (#6963258)
An "A-Player" is someone amazing at what they do and never satisfied with the status quo. These are the kind of people that crank out an MVP that will need to be replaced as soon as you start to scale. They are (generally) terrible in teams, but necessary to keep a company from becoming complacent and thus slowly dying.

A "B-Player" is someone competent. These are the people that do most of the work to make a solid product. A sizable company needs to be 80%+ B-players to be stable in the long term. On the other hand, a company of only B-players is prone to disruption from those better able to respond to the market.

"C-Players" are the people who don't contribute much, or even drag down the company. They may be incompetent or have a poisonous attitude. Too many C-players will doom a company to failure.

These definitions are how "A-Player" and so on are described to big corporations, so YMMV with startups and small companies.

Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by alan_cx on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @11:53AM (#6963373)
I see the answers given, and have to wonder if they know we are talking people and not slabs of warm meat.
Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by dictum on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @04:35PM (#6964340)
USDA Prime beef won't complain when it's rewarded for the 60-hour work weeks with a firing.
Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by thatthatis on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @09:48AM (#6963078)
In American education an "A" grade is 90% or higher, a "B" grade is 80-90% and a "C" grade is 70-80%

"A" player usually means someone in the top tier academically or professionally.

As far as I know it isn't used in American sporting.

Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by caoilte on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @10:13AM (#6963127)
Wow, your tests must be easy.
Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by caw on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @01:17PM (#6963703)
Or there's a curve so you fit each letter to 10% of participants. Generally it's a bell curve though so most people end up in C, since that's "average" or "satisfactory".

I had a few classes in college, where in a very 1984-esque fashion, failing (<60% correct) was passing. You just had to fail less than everyone else.

Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by forgottenpass on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @10:27AM (#6963164)
That was the quick and easy answer. Testing that doesn't expect mastery of the material will, of course, work differently.
Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by phamilton on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @11:13AM (#6963251)
C means satisfactory. B means above average. A means exceptional.

The expectation is a 70%. It is expected that the average student will get almost 1/3 wrong.

However, recent grade inflation has skewed the original meaning of these definitions

Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by bartonfink on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @09:48AM (#6963080)
I believe Joel Spolsky coined those terms in an essay about hiring. The reference is to American grading - letter grades are A (best), B, C, D and F.

He didn't, that I recall, define where the difference between an A and a B player was, so it's kind of a difficult metaphor to apply. It's really got nothing to do with any American sport that I know of - those terms would be more like "bench player", "starter" or "utility player".

Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by fit2rule on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @10:17AM (#6963140)
Well, whether its derived from sports or not, I still find the terminology to be quite discriminatory. What justifies this, I wonder?

Its possible that everyone in the world is an A-player, given the right chance. But with rampant discrimination going on, I doubt the chance is ever granted in a company that uses this terminology to manage itself ..

Re:Netflix: Non-'A' Players Unworthy of Jobs by mdwrigh2 on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @11:05AM (#6963238)
> Its possible that everyone in the world is an A-player, given the right chance.

Perhaps. Perhaps they just need more training, or experience, or... But the fact is, at a given point in time, some developers are more productive than others.