News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former BP geologist: peak oil is here and it will 'break ... by coldtea on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:20PM (#6960189)
>On the other side, we have some people who have always forecast an imminent heat death of Malthusian malaise for us all. Those people have never been right, so I'd say they bear the burden of proof that This Time It's Different.

Never been right? They'd been right in predicting the Big Depression. They'd been right saying this "gold rush" thing was BS.

Heck, there were people who predicted the decline and fall of Rome quite accurately. There were people who predicted the dot-com bust quite adequately. There were people who warned about the dangers of Nazi germany (or even the dangers of the Versailles treaty) before it was even a consideration for most. There were people who warned about the housing market bubble quite adequately.

Now, as for why those people (doing the warning) might seem to be wrong more often that others saying it's all OK.

Consider someone playing russian roulette -- perhaps with a 20 bullet chamber. Some other guy warns him: what are you doing, are you crazy? But he pulls the trigger and nothing happens. The other guy warns him again, stop it man, you'll kill yourself. Again, nothing happens. This goes on for a while, until at some point, say the 14th try, the guy blows his brains out.

Well, this same thing happened with situations like the recent economic crash.

Now, some people view it like the person giving the warning was wrong 13 times, and only right once. They'll say, dismisingly, "Well of course he eventually got it right: he always kept to the same warning even when he was wrong. Even a broken watch tells the right time 2 times a day, etc".

But I'd argue that that person was right ALL ALONG. Even when nothing had yet happened. And that if some other kind of action was chosen as he warned it should be (e.g putting the gun down), the tragedy would have been avoided.

Re:Former BP geologist: peak oil is here and it will 'break ... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @04:28PM (#6961191)
And we got over all that stuff, and emerged stronger.

The Russian Roulette analogy is not applicable because we're not discussing random processes.

Re:Former BP geologist: peak oil is here and it will 'break ... by coldtea on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @07:20PM (#6961684)
>And we got over all that stuff, and emerged stronger.

What, out of the recession? That's fairy tale level denial. The thing is still going strong, and it's not even close to over yet. Neither is the US economy coming out stonger at this point.

>The Russian Roulette analogy is not applicable because we're not discussing random processes.

Actually it's perfectly applicable.

For one, the processes we're discussing are essentially stochastic -- there are so many random factors playing into the economy at any given time.

Second, as with the russian roulette, the long term result after a specific consistent course of action is extremely deterministic (you blow your brains in one case, or you fuck up the economy in the other).