As a consequence, 'Free exchange' then consists of people with massively unequal bargaining powers coming to an agreement. To see this arrangement as fair, one has to twist their sight up quite a bit.
A defense of the free market without redistribution to counter the effects of this and other historical crimes is a defense of oligarchical privilege.
Who will redistribute in a practical way? Who watches that person to make sure they are both efficient and fair?
Also - look at a list of the richest people in America. You'll notice that most came from middle or low class backgrounds. It seems like redistribution occurs fairly rapidly (within one or two generations) compared with other times.
Also - please explain who in America has massively unequal bargaining powers?
In another comment you said you needed to use "counter propoganda". The internet and forums are largely dominated by your way of thinking. Maybe it's because people who hold your view would rather type about issues than do solid work.
And I've also been thinking about this practically. It is right that claims on property, the foundation of many forms of capitalist forms of economies, are not inherent. However couldn't powerful property taxes be useful as this? If we defined property well and taxed ownership then redistribution would be built in and taxes would fall on the richest (those who use the most resources)? I'm just playing with that idea.
Also - there is one prominent example of someone living on $7,000 a year comfortably (early retirement extreme) which is far below the minimum wage. This person lives a lifestyle far better than almost anyone two generations ago and most a generation ago.
Capitalism results in inequality regardless of initial conditions, because people differ in their abilities, and in their luck.
A much more powerful argument for redistribution than capitalism original sin, is that (1) we all live in a society, where we rely on the state to provide the security and infrastructure in which the free market is even possible, and (2) redistribution is the least intrusive, least restrictive method of improving societal wellbeing. It is (potentially) completely indifferent and blind to everything a person is and does, except for their total income.
I know this argument seems weaker because it involves utilitarian aspects, but it is really a more powerful argument because it doesn't rely on an accident of history.
There are a variety of other arguments you could advance against it - for example that the self is social fiction with no scientific basis, the increasing communality of all labor, the inherent instability of Capitalism evidenced by the Long Wave cycle, the sociological fact that people's consciousness is shaped by their relationship to the means of production (evidenced, on their part, by their almost uniformly advantaged upbringings)...
Speaking for myself, I have lost my taste for extended intellectual debate on the internet, and all of these vectors of criticism would (if I were being intellectually honest) lead to extended debate. It may not be fair of me, but as a Marxist I do believe that the material world will change much more workers minds than some logic arguments arrayed in an online discussion.
Suppose, for example, you manage to prove to a libertarian that the current distribution of wealth is the result of unfair actions in the past. Then for them, the next best option would probably be to redistribute wealth, and then press "play". Which isn't what you wanted to argue for in the first place, so why make that argument?
You say you have lost your taste for intellectual debate online, but I think you would regain it if you were to engage in real debate rather than point-scoring.
Your starting point is that you know the truth, and it is "material" factors that prevent others from knowing this truth. But to have this point of view underestimates the power of debate and reason. But of course I can't really convince you that I haven't been subconsciously made blind to the intellectual power of Marxism by my comfortable middle class lifestyle.
Probably true; I guess my comment can thought of more as counter-propaganda.
>Suppose, for example...
I imagine if I could get someone to question the premises of their hateful, retrograde philosophy I could get them to engage in further inquiry, which might open their eyes.
>You say you have lost your taste for intellectual debate online...
True, but I could also cultivate other interests. I'm sure eventually it will entice me again,
>Your starting point is that you know the truth
Marxists don't believe in absolute truth.
Do 'debate and reason' derive their power from the material world? It seems to me that they only exercise power in shaping one's consciousness to the degree that they reflect facts about the material world.
Following on the heels of that, what facts about a humans physical presence in the world carry more import for every other facet of their life than their economic position (position meaning, in particular, class)?
For what it's worth, people can and do argue against economic determinism. The degree of success that they have in that regard is a matter of continuing debate.
1) People freely exchange goods and services.
2) Wealth is distributed without free exchange.
It's a spectrum not an absolute.
In free exchange (me trading with my boss or with Google or with a grocery store) I will never enter into a trade that has a lower expected value than the dollar value I'm giving up. In other words in every exchange I will either gain value or match value.
On the second side of the spectrum I (me with the government, me with a slaver) will enter into a trade regardless of its outcome - meaning that I could lose value on any trade (for instance by paying into a poorly run social program, supporting a war that I disagree with or paying to be spied on). Also closer to the second range there becomes a coercive aspect where I am forced into something at the threat of violence (pay taxes or go to prison).
Evidence shows the more freely exchanged goods and services there are (with some exceptions) the more productive the country. See: http://www.freetheworld.com/release.html
If strong property laws are in place alongside an impartial justice system and limited government (one not influenced by wealth) human choice, good or bad, is respected and freedom reigns. When government is large and powerful or the justice system doesn't function properly (can be bought) coercion reigns.
Those who would rather not provide value (or believe that their value is worth more than others will give them for it) may prefer the coercive side.