News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The case against Kim Dotcom, finally revealed by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:55AM (#6958441)
> The relevant technological shift isn't that it's become easier to produce content that people want.

Isn't it though? The studios are now having to compete for viewer attention with everything from lolcats to Open Courseware lectures to porn. It isn't that there is nothing on YouTube worth watching, it's that in order to find the videos worth watching you have to wade through an ocean of diarrhea. Those are two quite separate things, and a proper solution to the second would probably put Hollywood out of business.

And your two markets (content creation and distribution) are not so unrelated. The copyright monopoly only applies to the work, not to fungible replacement works in the market for e.g. two hours of video entertainment. In a competitive market we would expect low profits because high profits would encourage new entrants until competition reduces profits to only just cover costs. The studios have historically claimed much higher profits than this primarily by cartelizing content distribution. It didn't matter in 1985 if you and your buddies could make a better movie with a camcorder than Disney had in theaters, it was still Disney's movies that would appear on the screens.

Which is the real trouble from Hollywood's perspective about a service like MegaUpload: They're distributing Hollywood content in the same channels as content made by the proles. If Hollywood came to MegaUpload and said "you are distributing our content on your site, kindly raise prices a bit and cut us in," the result would be for everyone involved to make a lot of money. But Hollywood won't have any of that anywhere -- there are no lolcats permitted on Hulu or Netflix, and far be it for the latest blockbuster or TV episode to be available on YouTube. Because they're trying to preserve their control over the distribution channels as much as possible for as long as possible.

In the end it's going to bite them too. What they need is an open distribution system that will prevent someone from doing to them what Apple did to the recording industry. A free market for video content, where the market itself is (like the internet) not owned or controlled by anybody in particular and anybody can show up with content to sell and anybody can buy it for any device. The only difference between that and the collection of "piracy sites" the likes of MegaUpload -- the only difference you actually want -- is for people who download to pay money to the creators of the things they downloaded. But Hollywood won't allow that sort of competition in content distribution, because it requires giving up the attempt to monopolize distribution for themselves, the exclusive contracts with specific distributors, etc.

There are no comments on this comment yet.