Of course, in an ideal world we wouldn't have a black hat SEO arms race. But as you mentioned, Stack Overflow managed to flourish without resorting to those tactics. The context is important, but it doesn't forgive their actions.
> rapgenius might say here, 'don't hate the playa hate teh game son!'
That's a nice phrase, but I think I'm going to go ahead and hate both.
> Stack Overflow managed to flourish without resorting to those tactics
Well, or Stack Overflow managed to flourish without resorting to those tactics and getting found out.
[subs - please insert dramatic chipmunk here]
I am not sure they are directly comparable - unless rappers themselves are choosing the site, just like programmers themselves (ourselves) voted with our feet. Aren't people searching for lyrics more of a casual browser type?
rapgenius might say here, 'don't hate the playa hate teh game son!'